This post first published May 7, 2014.
Author: Kristin von Kreisler
First Published: December 31, 2013
Publisher: Kensington Books
252 pages (paperback)
I purchased this book out of spontaneity, as it was on sale at Wal
Mart; as well, the adorable Golden Retriever on the cover caught my
attention. The synopsis on the back cover also sounded like something I
would be interested in reading. Sad to say, but this was a regretful
purchase. It was underwhelming, and the story felt like it lacked heart.
The book is about a woman named Lila Elliot, an aspiring artist who
works an ordinary office job. One day, at work, an ex-colleague came in
and shoots up the place, killing some and injuring many. Lila is one
such injured victim. Her best friend Cristina takes Lila in at her home
to take care of her after the incident, at the same time she is
fostering a previously abused dog, a Golden Retriever, named Grace. Lila
hates dogs but puts up with Grace to be thankful for Cristina’s
generosity and care.
Not too long afterwards, Cristina has to leave with her husband and
children for six months (for a business trip of her husband’s). She asks
Lila to continue staying at her home, rent-free, and insisting she pick
up her artistry again. Her only request is that Lila also take care of
Grace, with her ulterior motive being that maybe Lila will like Grace
and adopt her. Lila is extremely hesitant to do this, but in the end
agrees. Over time, Lila and Grace bond, helping one another let go of
their respective pasts and moving forward in life.
Having finished this book in its entirety, my first feeling was one
of relief — that this book is over. It just … wasn’t very good. My
biggest complaint is the character of Lila. There was absolutely nothing
to like about Lila, and she was kind of creepy as well. I get it, she
was a victim and was suffering from some undiagnosed PTSD, but the way
she was written just made me want to shake her shoulders and tell her
to, “Let it go!!!” Examples: she began to make wide sweeping
generalizations about men being evil, she began to stalk the family
members of her shooter to find “closure”, she moaned and complained at
home about being helpless to do anything, she was rude and mean to the
people who wanted to help her … and more. What’s more, a big part of the
book was centered on Lila finding closure with the shooting. Yet, in
the end, she anti-climatically decides that, whatever, he was just a
psycho.
Her relationship with Grace, the Golden Retriever, was eye roll
worthy. First of all, it was established that Lila hates dogs (due to
her idiocy in childhood of approaching a stray dog that ended up biting
her hand, but she’s convinced herself that all dogs are just people
killers now, whatever). So, her best friend Cristina thinks it’s a good
idea to have Lila, who is in recovery and can barely care for herself,
take care of a dog, alone, while she is away …? That was the first thing
that made me questioned the common sense of all these characters. So
naturally, Lila hates Grace the whole time, thinking Grace is going to
chew her up to bits, even though Grace has done NOTHING to make her
think she is aggressive. Then one day, Lila decides to give Grace away,
only to have second thoughts and claim Grace back. All of a sudden, Lila
is in love with Grace and can’t live without her. Talk about a 180
degree turn! There was no building of a relationship at all, Lila just
went from hating Grace to being best friends with Grace in less than a
day. I craved an explanation as to how a person who hated dogs most of
her life can become a fervent dog lover after attempting to give the dog
away, but there was no explanation.
Then for the next several chapters, Lila and Grace’s relationship
took a backseat to Lila’s relationship with male character, Adam. Adam
is a neighbour and the one who brought Grace to Cristina’s home
initially looking for a home for her. Lila disliked Adam from the
beginning and was quite rude to him. Adam was actually the only
character I thought that had any sense in this story, and actually told
Lila off a couple times for being overly negative and irresponsible.
Suddenly one day, after Adam helps Lila give Grace a dog bath, Lila
finds Adam super attractive and goes on dates with him and yeah, they
are together. I have no idea what they saw in one another all of a
sudden, because every interaction between them prior was rather
negative.
I also think this story has some minor illogical plot hole stuff
going on. I couldn’t stop questioning why Cristina and Adam insisted
Grace had to be kept at Cristina’s home while they found a new home for
her. The story is that Adam stole the dog from his neighbour who had
been abusing the dog, and put her at Cristina’s house temporarily while
they found a new home. Adam even said they had to keep it a bit hush
hush since he didn’t want the neighbour to know he stole Grace. However,
they put up posters around town with Grace’s picture (a photo that
INCLUDES Adam!) to try to find her a home. Are they not worried that the
neighbour will see the posters?!
I’m wholly unimpressed with this novel. The lack of proper
relationship building between characters was my biggest issue. I don’t
even really see how Grace helped Lila heal at all, or vice versa. I
expected a warm, touching story between human and dog and instead, got a
very lackluster story about the world’s most annoying gunshot victim
ever.
My Rating: 1/5
Showing posts with label 1. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1. Show all posts
Friday, October 2, 2015
An Unexpected Grace
Sweet Evil
This post first published August 28, 2012.
Author: Wendy Higgins
Series: Sweet Evil #1
First Published: May 2012
Publisher: HarperTeen
464 pages (eBook)
I am kind of in a state of disbelief over this book. I mean that in a, “What did I just read?” kind of way. It started off pretty good but very, very quickly went downhill for me. I just can’t believe over half the things that happened in this book. I’m surprised I actually read every word to the end.
Sweet Evil is about a girl named Anna. She’s super sweet and innocent, incredibly nice, and also, she can literally see people’s emotions, in colours. She’s always known she was kind of different from other people, obviously. When she turns 16, she meets Kaidan, a deliciously handsome teen boy who’s in a famous rock band. He’s the same as her — he can see people’s emotions, but the difference is, he knows why. Anna and Kaidan are Nephilim, the offspring of demons and humans. Born to one of the Dukes of Evil, their jobs is to corrupt humankind and have them destroy one another in sin. However, Anna is even more unique than she realizes — she is not the daughter of a demon and a human, but rather, a demon and an angel.
There are so many things I didn’t like about this book. I’ll start with the story and structure. I really did not like having the story world explained to me via question-answer sessions between characters. I can think of at least three long scenes where Anna is sat down with another characters (Kaidan, her foster mom Patti, or her dad) and they just explain things to her. It was like reading an interview, where Anna would ask a question and the other person would provide an answer. I find this to be a very boring and unimaginative way of revealing a story world.
A lot of events happened in this book that were just super unrealistic, and I don’t mean the demons and spirits and angels. The majority of characters in this book are 15-17. Somehow, every teen is hooked onto drinking and ecstasy and having sex, or so it seems. At age FIFTEEN? Holy cow. Maybe I just wasn’t “hip” when I was 15, but that seems awfully young to be doing these things. Not only that, but it’s incredibly easy for them to enter clubs and bars. I have no idea why. I highly doubt all the bouncers do is slap a bracelet on your hand that says you’re a minor. As the kids in this book showed, even with these magical bracelets, they got their hands on booze very easily. And wow, were they ever knowledgeable about alcohol, they knew so many drinks and mixes, it was mind boggling.
The characters were ridiculous. Anna is supposed to be super innocent, kind and a little naive. Well, she definitely came off naive, and very dumb, and very annoying. She’s stuck in this world where she wants everyone to hold hands and ring around the rosy. She’s also hypocritical. For example, Kaidan, being the son of the Duke of Lust, kept wanting to have sex with her. She kept refusing. Finally, one night, she randomly pounced on Kaidan, totally wanting to have sex with him because — get this — her poetry homework made her mad. Kaidan wasn’t great either. I saw no reason why the two of them fell in love after four days (Anna even admits it’s only been 4 days), but they did. Kaidan had little personality and the only thing he wanted from Anna nearly the entire time was to have sex with her, which Anna kept refusing yet she fell in love … Weird.
Anna’s parents were really aggravating too, especially her mom. Anna’s foster mom, Patti, is your stereotypical helicopter mom. At the same time, she makes dumb parenting decisions. Anna needs to go to California to meet her dad — why not go on a road trip with Kaidan, the boy you met yesterday? Yes, you know he’s the son of a demon, that should be no problem because you’ll just go right up to him and tell him to leave Anna’s virtue intact. He’ll listen to you, right? And then there’s Anna’s dad. She hasn’t seen him in 16 years, yet once they were in each other’s lives, they acted like they’ve always known one another, being super close and everything. It was bizarre. Not to mention how extremely uncomfortable it was to read about her dad bringing TONS of alcohol to her and teaching her how to drink alcohol so she can lure other people to drink and become drunk. She’s SIXTEEN. I don’t care if that’s her job as a demon child, she’s SIXTEEN! It did not inspire any warm and fuzzy father-daughter moments in me at all.
On a similar note, I do understand that this book centers around these demons that are each in charge of a sin, but I felt like the amount of it in the book was almost at inappropriate levels for a YA/teen novel. There’s SO much drugs and alcohol in this book which the characters drink with no consequences. Kaidan’s job is to have sex with girls, so he’s having one night stands in every other chapter. We have two twin girls whose job is to break up relationships and marriages. One of them describes being gang raped at age 13. Anna herself almost gets date raped. Who thought all this would be okay in a book with characters who are so young?! If this was an adult/general fiction book, that’s different, but this isn’t. I also disliked how this book emphasized virginity = purity. Implying that if you’re not a virgin, you’re a dirty, dirty whore, which is something some of the female characters who are not virgins experienced when the other kids at school found out they had sex with so and so.
I can go on forever about what I didn’t like about this book, but I think you get the point. There’s so many things I dislike about it and the story seemed to make less and less sense as the book went on. It’s really strange because when I first started the book, I actually really enjoyed the first chapter and was looking forward to some YA demon-angel mythology. I am definitely not interested in reading any more from this series :|
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Wendy Higgins
Series: Sweet Evil #1
First Published: May 2012
Publisher: HarperTeen
464 pages (eBook)
I am kind of in a state of disbelief over this book. I mean that in a, “What did I just read?” kind of way. It started off pretty good but very, very quickly went downhill for me. I just can’t believe over half the things that happened in this book. I’m surprised I actually read every word to the end.
Sweet Evil is about a girl named Anna. She’s super sweet and innocent, incredibly nice, and also, she can literally see people’s emotions, in colours. She’s always known she was kind of different from other people, obviously. When she turns 16, she meets Kaidan, a deliciously handsome teen boy who’s in a famous rock band. He’s the same as her — he can see people’s emotions, but the difference is, he knows why. Anna and Kaidan are Nephilim, the offspring of demons and humans. Born to one of the Dukes of Evil, their jobs is to corrupt humankind and have them destroy one another in sin. However, Anna is even more unique than she realizes — she is not the daughter of a demon and a human, but rather, a demon and an angel.
There are so many things I didn’t like about this book. I’ll start with the story and structure. I really did not like having the story world explained to me via question-answer sessions between characters. I can think of at least three long scenes where Anna is sat down with another characters (Kaidan, her foster mom Patti, or her dad) and they just explain things to her. It was like reading an interview, where Anna would ask a question and the other person would provide an answer. I find this to be a very boring and unimaginative way of revealing a story world.
A lot of events happened in this book that were just super unrealistic, and I don’t mean the demons and spirits and angels. The majority of characters in this book are 15-17. Somehow, every teen is hooked onto drinking and ecstasy and having sex, or so it seems. At age FIFTEEN? Holy cow. Maybe I just wasn’t “hip” when I was 15, but that seems awfully young to be doing these things. Not only that, but it’s incredibly easy for them to enter clubs and bars. I have no idea why. I highly doubt all the bouncers do is slap a bracelet on your hand that says you’re a minor. As the kids in this book showed, even with these magical bracelets, they got their hands on booze very easily. And wow, were they ever knowledgeable about alcohol, they knew so many drinks and mixes, it was mind boggling.
The characters were ridiculous. Anna is supposed to be super innocent, kind and a little naive. Well, she definitely came off naive, and very dumb, and very annoying. She’s stuck in this world where she wants everyone to hold hands and ring around the rosy. She’s also hypocritical. For example, Kaidan, being the son of the Duke of Lust, kept wanting to have sex with her. She kept refusing. Finally, one night, she randomly pounced on Kaidan, totally wanting to have sex with him because — get this — her poetry homework made her mad. Kaidan wasn’t great either. I saw no reason why the two of them fell in love after four days (Anna even admits it’s only been 4 days), but they did. Kaidan had little personality and the only thing he wanted from Anna nearly the entire time was to have sex with her, which Anna kept refusing yet she fell in love … Weird.
Anna’s parents were really aggravating too, especially her mom. Anna’s foster mom, Patti, is your stereotypical helicopter mom. At the same time, she makes dumb parenting decisions. Anna needs to go to California to meet her dad — why not go on a road trip with Kaidan, the boy you met yesterday? Yes, you know he’s the son of a demon, that should be no problem because you’ll just go right up to him and tell him to leave Anna’s virtue intact. He’ll listen to you, right? And then there’s Anna’s dad. She hasn’t seen him in 16 years, yet once they were in each other’s lives, they acted like they’ve always known one another, being super close and everything. It was bizarre. Not to mention how extremely uncomfortable it was to read about her dad bringing TONS of alcohol to her and teaching her how to drink alcohol so she can lure other people to drink and become drunk. She’s SIXTEEN. I don’t care if that’s her job as a demon child, she’s SIXTEEN! It did not inspire any warm and fuzzy father-daughter moments in me at all.
On a similar note, I do understand that this book centers around these demons that are each in charge of a sin, but I felt like the amount of it in the book was almost at inappropriate levels for a YA/teen novel. There’s SO much drugs and alcohol in this book which the characters drink with no consequences. Kaidan’s job is to have sex with girls, so he’s having one night stands in every other chapter. We have two twin girls whose job is to break up relationships and marriages. One of them describes being gang raped at age 13. Anna herself almost gets date raped. Who thought all this would be okay in a book with characters who are so young?! If this was an adult/general fiction book, that’s different, but this isn’t. I also disliked how this book emphasized virginity = purity. Implying that if you’re not a virgin, you’re a dirty, dirty whore, which is something some of the female characters who are not virgins experienced when the other kids at school found out they had sex with so and so.
I can go on forever about what I didn’t like about this book, but I think you get the point. There’s so many things I dislike about it and the story seemed to make less and less sense as the book went on. It’s really strange because when I first started the book, I actually really enjoyed the first chapter and was looking forward to some YA demon-angel mythology. I am definitely not interested in reading any more from this series :|
My Rating: 1/5
Gardens of the Moon
This post first published July 5, 2012.
Author: Steven Erikson
First Published: January 1999
Publisher: Bantam Books
Series: Malazan Book of the Fallen #1
752 pages (mass market paperback)
Oh god, I’m finally done this book. I’ve had this book for just over a year, I totally bought it impulsively. I had heard nothing about it before I got it, just wanted to read a fantasy novel. Well, now I’m done this book, and it was, unfortunately, an ordeal to get through it. I cleaned out my bookshelf yesterday, and I think this book is going in my “to donate” pile of books to bring to the thrift store.
I’ve got a lot of issues with this book. The biggest thing is that it’s difficult to follow. The writing isn’t the best, and there’s weird scene transitions and absolutely no explanations about anything. My copy of the book includes an introduction by the author, and he says in his introduction that he purposely didn’t want to have to explain everything because he didn’t want to dumb down his story, which in turn may be insulting to his readers’ intelligence. Okay, fair enough. However, I don’t think it was handled very well. Some explanation or hints would have been nice. I don’t know how I’m supposed to know which characters were on which side, are what ranking, etc. without a little help. A lot of terms also went right over my head; I still don’t really know what a Warden is, or what a T’lan Imass is. I have a vague idea but still not really sure.
So, the book was confusing. I’m usually prepared to be a little confused at first when I start a new fantasy series. Fantasy series seem to like to drop readers into the middle of the world and have you work your way around the story-verse yourself, which is fine. I usually am able to sort everything out 50-100 pages in (which is nothing, considering how long these books usually are) and then just enjoy the story from there. With Gardens of the Moon, I was on page 600 out of 752 and still had no idea what I was reading about, just a lot of assassins, gods and running around on rooftops …
I mean, I sort of got the gist of the story. The Empire, led by Empress Laseen, tried to take over the city of Pale in the beginning. Pale was helped by Moon’s Spawn (which I had to look up on the Internet — it’s a floating fortress), but eventually Pale falls. Then the rest of the book shifts to the characters wanting to take over or save, depending which side they are on, the last free city of Darujhistan. And there’s some gods who are involved with these mortals’ affairs, which is really putting a kink in Laseen’s plans. So yeah, I kind of get the story, but at the same time, I feel like I didn’t understand the story at all.
The characters and dialogue were rather poor as well. The characters were on the dull side. I didn’t feel invested in any of them, it was like no big deal when any of them died. The dialogue was overly dramatic and corny, also dull. It just wasn’t very engaging.
I do think the world was very intricately built and well done though, from what I can tell with my limited understanding. It’s obvious this book takes place in an immense world with a deep and rich history that spans thousands of years. I do feel a little sad that I was unable to enjoy this world; I did want to like it, but there were simply too many obstacles preventing me.
I have read that the first book is considered the weakest, even amongst fans of this series. I read somewhere that new readers are advised to simply start with the second book (there are new characters and stuff, so it’s not like a direct continuation from book one). At this point in time, I’m not sure if I want to give the series a second chance. I feel quite burnt out from fantasy reading this book, so if I do try the second book, it won’t be for a long time. Perhaps after I read some reviews/opinions on the second one first, then I will decide. As for this first book, I think if you are really, really into epic fantasies, into world building and super complicated fantasy plots, you can give this a try, but for any one else who just reads fantasy from time to time, you’ll probably want to skip this one.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Steven Erikson
First Published: January 1999
Publisher: Bantam Books
Series: Malazan Book of the Fallen #1
752 pages (mass market paperback)
Oh god, I’m finally done this book. I’ve had this book for just over a year, I totally bought it impulsively. I had heard nothing about it before I got it, just wanted to read a fantasy novel. Well, now I’m done this book, and it was, unfortunately, an ordeal to get through it. I cleaned out my bookshelf yesterday, and I think this book is going in my “to donate” pile of books to bring to the thrift store.
I’ve got a lot of issues with this book. The biggest thing is that it’s difficult to follow. The writing isn’t the best, and there’s weird scene transitions and absolutely no explanations about anything. My copy of the book includes an introduction by the author, and he says in his introduction that he purposely didn’t want to have to explain everything because he didn’t want to dumb down his story, which in turn may be insulting to his readers’ intelligence. Okay, fair enough. However, I don’t think it was handled very well. Some explanation or hints would have been nice. I don’t know how I’m supposed to know which characters were on which side, are what ranking, etc. without a little help. A lot of terms also went right over my head; I still don’t really know what a Warden is, or what a T’lan Imass is. I have a vague idea but still not really sure.
So, the book was confusing. I’m usually prepared to be a little confused at first when I start a new fantasy series. Fantasy series seem to like to drop readers into the middle of the world and have you work your way around the story-verse yourself, which is fine. I usually am able to sort everything out 50-100 pages in (which is nothing, considering how long these books usually are) and then just enjoy the story from there. With Gardens of the Moon, I was on page 600 out of 752 and still had no idea what I was reading about, just a lot of assassins, gods and running around on rooftops …
I mean, I sort of got the gist of the story. The Empire, led by Empress Laseen, tried to take over the city of Pale in the beginning. Pale was helped by Moon’s Spawn (which I had to look up on the Internet — it’s a floating fortress), but eventually Pale falls. Then the rest of the book shifts to the characters wanting to take over or save, depending which side they are on, the last free city of Darujhistan. And there’s some gods who are involved with these mortals’ affairs, which is really putting a kink in Laseen’s plans. So yeah, I kind of get the story, but at the same time, I feel like I didn’t understand the story at all.
The characters and dialogue were rather poor as well. The characters were on the dull side. I didn’t feel invested in any of them, it was like no big deal when any of them died. The dialogue was overly dramatic and corny, also dull. It just wasn’t very engaging.
I do think the world was very intricately built and well done though, from what I can tell with my limited understanding. It’s obvious this book takes place in an immense world with a deep and rich history that spans thousands of years. I do feel a little sad that I was unable to enjoy this world; I did want to like it, but there were simply too many obstacles preventing me.
I have read that the first book is considered the weakest, even amongst fans of this series. I read somewhere that new readers are advised to simply start with the second book (there are new characters and stuff, so it’s not like a direct continuation from book one). At this point in time, I’m not sure if I want to give the series a second chance. I feel quite burnt out from fantasy reading this book, so if I do try the second book, it won’t be for a long time. Perhaps after I read some reviews/opinions on the second one first, then I will decide. As for this first book, I think if you are really, really into epic fantasies, into world building and super complicated fantasy plots, you can give this a try, but for any one else who just reads fantasy from time to time, you’ll probably want to skip this one.
My Rating: 1/5
Thursday, October 1, 2015
Tris & Izzie
This post first published September 10, 2011.
Author: Mette Ivie Harrison
Published: October 11, 2011
Publisher: EgmontUSA
272 pages (galley)
I saw this available on NetGalley and I decided I want to read it — not so much based on the beautiful cover, but because of its incredibly low rating on Goodreads. I was fairly warned that I most likely will not like this book by a number of good friends of mine, but I was 1) curious and 2) believed it couldn’t really be that bad.
Well, I believed wrong.
Tris & Izzie is a modern re-telling of the legend Tristan and Iseult/Isolde/Yseult. I don’t actually know much about the legend; I watched the 2006 movie ages ago and don’t really remember much about it, just a general idea that it is a medieval romance. So I don’t really have the original story in my head to compare this novel to. (I did look up the legend after I finished this book though).
In this book, Izzie is dating the most popular boy in school, Mark. Lately, she doesn’t know why her best friend Branna is acting so weird around her and Mark, so she gets the brilliant idea to feed Branna and some guy (yes, literally, some guy — she doesn’t have anyone in mind yet) a love potion, courtesy of Izzie’s mom, who is a witch. When she tries to feed Branna the love potion, she gives some to Mark’s new friend Tristan. However, when Mark wants to drink some too, Izzie panics and drinks the rest herself, falling desperately in love with Tristan.
Izzie loves Tristan but is conflicted by her relationship with Mark, unsure of what to do. In the meantime, Izzie’s mom reveals that their family is from a place called Curvenal, where her mom did her witchcraft and her father (who is deceased) was a sorcerer. Izzie finds out that she is a sorceress herself, and that there is a great serpent who has been hunting her for the past 11 years. Tristan has been sent to protect Izzie.
There are a number of things that rubbed me the wrong way with this book, but the two biggest things was the execution and Izzie.
The execution — Well, this is supposed to be a modern retelling but it really, really does not feel like one. When I think of a modern retelling of an old story or legend, I imagine that there is no magic. You don’t modernize the story of Sleeping Beauty, but keep the fact that she fell asleep for a 100 years, that there were fairies, that there was a magic spinning wheel, etc. You reinvent all that to fit into the present day. You don’t simply throw the exact same story into a different time period. So, I don’t think this novel was a particularly creative reimagining of Tristan & Iseult (except the latter half of the novel, but by then, I don’t think it was retelling anything anymore).
I was actually very surprised when all the witchcraft and potions was brought up. It was not a smooth introduction at all. I thought I was reading a contemporary, non-fantasy novel and all of a sudden, Izzie and Branna are talking about potions and magic in a high school hallway like it’s completely normal. That wouldn’t have been too bad, but the magic system or world building in this book was poor as well, as if it was not thoroughly thought out. At first you think the magic in this world is witchcraft and potions. Okay. Suddenly we find out Izzie is a sorceress who can wield elemental magic. And then suddenly we find out Tristan is an alchemist. And then we find out about a whole bunch of strange mythical beasts that exist. More and more magical elements were just being thrown together. That was why I was not surprised when Tristan announced he had a flying sword.
The latter half of the novel seemed kind of ridiculous, with the giant and Izzie learning to wield fireballs out of the blue. For someone who only found out she has magic in her blood a few hours ago, she’s skilled enough to duel Albus Dumbledore and possibly win. It just didn’t really fit. I suppose you could say that’s just how the magic works in this world — if you have magic in your blood, you can do anything! But that goes back to my earlier statement that the magic in this novel is not properly thought out.
Izzie — I have never despised a character so much. She is the most selfish, immature, self-centered, idiotic and shallow character I have ever met. For one, she doesn’t realize Branna is in love with her boyfriend Mark when it is blatantly obvious. Then she takes it upon herself to force Branna to fall in love with someone of Izzie’s own choosing, with a love potion, without her consent, because she believes she knows what’s good for her best friend. When Izzie was in the hospital, she bossed Mark around, demanding him to get her a wheelchair and throwing a hissy fit when he didn’t leap to his feet to obey. When Branna was seriously injured, Izzie spent a considerable amount of time admiring Tristan’s athletic form instead of worrying about her friend.
I was so happy with the scene where Mark punched Izzie in the face. She deserved it. It’s unfortunate that she’s apparently made of steel or something because it didn’t seem to have much of an effect on her, not even a bruise.
The other characters weren’t much better. Tristan spoke super formally, which made him sound rather monotone. I thought this was supposed to be a romance, but there is surprisingly very little Tristan in this book. Or maybe it’s just because he doesn’t talk too much. Branna and Mark had one personality trait apiece. Speaking of which, Mark was quite odd because as soon as he found out Izzie didn’t love him anymore, but that Branna has a huge crush on him, he changed his tune quite quickly. Suddenly, instead of proclaiming his love for Izzie, he was swearing his eternal undying love to Branna. No magic (or reasonable transition of feelings) involved.
The biggest dealbreaker was that the writing wasn’t very good. The dialogue especially, felt quite unnatural (and I’m not just talking about Tristan’s robot voice). Some of the things that came out of the characters’ mouths just didn’t feel like something someone would say if they were in that situation.
This book wasn’t boring though, I’ll give you that. It was … interesting. I kept reading mainly because I kept being shocked and/or appalled by the things Izzie does or says (or busy being angry at Izzie), and the way the story developed was just so utterly bizarre that I kept reading.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Mette Ivie Harrison
Published: October 11, 2011
Publisher: EgmontUSA
272 pages (galley)
I saw this available on NetGalley and I decided I want to read it — not so much based on the beautiful cover, but because of its incredibly low rating on Goodreads. I was fairly warned that I most likely will not like this book by a number of good friends of mine, but I was 1) curious and 2) believed it couldn’t really be that bad.
Well, I believed wrong.
Tris & Izzie is a modern re-telling of the legend Tristan and Iseult/Isolde/Yseult. I don’t actually know much about the legend; I watched the 2006 movie ages ago and don’t really remember much about it, just a general idea that it is a medieval romance. So I don’t really have the original story in my head to compare this novel to. (I did look up the legend after I finished this book though).
In this book, Izzie is dating the most popular boy in school, Mark. Lately, she doesn’t know why her best friend Branna is acting so weird around her and Mark, so she gets the brilliant idea to feed Branna and some guy (yes, literally, some guy — she doesn’t have anyone in mind yet) a love potion, courtesy of Izzie’s mom, who is a witch. When she tries to feed Branna the love potion, she gives some to Mark’s new friend Tristan. However, when Mark wants to drink some too, Izzie panics and drinks the rest herself, falling desperately in love with Tristan.
Izzie loves Tristan but is conflicted by her relationship with Mark, unsure of what to do. In the meantime, Izzie’s mom reveals that their family is from a place called Curvenal, where her mom did her witchcraft and her father (who is deceased) was a sorcerer. Izzie finds out that she is a sorceress herself, and that there is a great serpent who has been hunting her for the past 11 years. Tristan has been sent to protect Izzie.
There are a number of things that rubbed me the wrong way with this book, but the two biggest things was the execution and Izzie.
The execution — Well, this is supposed to be a modern retelling but it really, really does not feel like one. When I think of a modern retelling of an old story or legend, I imagine that there is no magic. You don’t modernize the story of Sleeping Beauty, but keep the fact that she fell asleep for a 100 years, that there were fairies, that there was a magic spinning wheel, etc. You reinvent all that to fit into the present day. You don’t simply throw the exact same story into a different time period. So, I don’t think this novel was a particularly creative reimagining of Tristan & Iseult (except the latter half of the novel, but by then, I don’t think it was retelling anything anymore).
I was actually very surprised when all the witchcraft and potions was brought up. It was not a smooth introduction at all. I thought I was reading a contemporary, non-fantasy novel and all of a sudden, Izzie and Branna are talking about potions and magic in a high school hallway like it’s completely normal. That wouldn’t have been too bad, but the magic system or world building in this book was poor as well, as if it was not thoroughly thought out. At first you think the magic in this world is witchcraft and potions. Okay. Suddenly we find out Izzie is a sorceress who can wield elemental magic. And then suddenly we find out Tristan is an alchemist. And then we find out about a whole bunch of strange mythical beasts that exist. More and more magical elements were just being thrown together. That was why I was not surprised when Tristan announced he had a flying sword.
The latter half of the novel seemed kind of ridiculous, with the giant and Izzie learning to wield fireballs out of the blue. For someone who only found out she has magic in her blood a few hours ago, she’s skilled enough to duel Albus Dumbledore and possibly win. It just didn’t really fit. I suppose you could say that’s just how the magic works in this world — if you have magic in your blood, you can do anything! But that goes back to my earlier statement that the magic in this novel is not properly thought out.
Izzie — I have never despised a character so much. She is the most selfish, immature, self-centered, idiotic and shallow character I have ever met. For one, she doesn’t realize Branna is in love with her boyfriend Mark when it is blatantly obvious. Then she takes it upon herself to force Branna to fall in love with someone of Izzie’s own choosing, with a love potion, without her consent, because she believes she knows what’s good for her best friend. When Izzie was in the hospital, she bossed Mark around, demanding him to get her a wheelchair and throwing a hissy fit when he didn’t leap to his feet to obey. When Branna was seriously injured, Izzie spent a considerable amount of time admiring Tristan’s athletic form instead of worrying about her friend.
I was so happy with the scene where Mark punched Izzie in the face. She deserved it. It’s unfortunate that she’s apparently made of steel or something because it didn’t seem to have much of an effect on her, not even a bruise.
The other characters weren’t much better. Tristan spoke super formally, which made him sound rather monotone. I thought this was supposed to be a romance, but there is surprisingly very little Tristan in this book. Or maybe it’s just because he doesn’t talk too much. Branna and Mark had one personality trait apiece. Speaking of which, Mark was quite odd because as soon as he found out Izzie didn’t love him anymore, but that Branna has a huge crush on him, he changed his tune quite quickly. Suddenly, instead of proclaiming his love for Izzie, he was swearing his eternal undying love to Branna. No magic (or reasonable transition of feelings) involved.
The biggest dealbreaker was that the writing wasn’t very good. The dialogue especially, felt quite unnatural (and I’m not just talking about Tristan’s robot voice). Some of the things that came out of the characters’ mouths just didn’t feel like something someone would say if they were in that situation.
This book wasn’t boring though, I’ll give you that. It was … interesting. I kept reading mainly because I kept being shocked and/or appalled by the things Izzie does or says (or busy being angry at Izzie), and the way the story developed was just so utterly bizarre that I kept reading.
My Rating: 1/5
Labels:
1,
mette ivie harrison,
romance,
urban fantasy,
young adult
Fallen
This post first published September 7, 2011.
Author: Lauren Kate
Published: December 2009
Publisher: Doubleday
Series: Fallen #1
452 (paperback)
I have a weakness for books with beautiful covers, and Fallen has a very beautiful cover indeed. Except I don’t think the story inside the book lives up to the packaging. I am not even completely sure what I just read. After finishing the book, I am left with way too many questions, and I don’t feel like anything was really resolved … was there even anything to resolve? I got this book because the majority of my Goodreads friends gave it a high rating, but maybe I should have heeded the ratings of my non-friends more seriously. (Sorry, friends …)
If you’ve read Twilight, Hush Hush, Evermore, Elixir, Dead Beautiful, The Mephisto Covenant, (insert another YA paranormal romance here), you’ve read half this book already. Luce has been troubled by the black shadows she sees for years. She has been pretending she’s completely normal for years, until recently at a high school party, she may or may not have accidentally killed her crush in a fire. And we never find out more about that event because the point of all that is to give a reason for Luce to enter Sword & Cross, a reform school.
Right away, Luce spots Daniel Grigori, who is, of course, drop dead gorgeous, has a “muscled torso” (naturally; he wouldn’t be a very good YA paranormal romance male lead without one), and seems a bit tortured. Their relationship feels a lot like Bella and Edward — Luce performs some Insta-Love™. Daniel tries to stay away from Luce at first, and isn’t very nice to her. Daniel saves Luce from a falling statue, like Edward saved Bella from an incoming car. Luce is still attracted to Daniel despite his efforts to tell her to stay away for her own good. Luce decides to go all stalker-like and literally research Daniel by digging through his school files, using the Internet and looking up his ancestors.
Oh, and the entire time, Luce is pursued by another guy, who is equally good looking, called Cam. Cam actually shows interest in Luce, and expresses how fond of her he is and even buys her a necklace. But no, Luce wants the guy who is trying his best to ignore her. Seriously boggles my mind. (And yes, Cam turns out to be the antagonist. Why??)
At no point in the story did I understand why Luce and Daniel love one another. They just do. They’re soulmates. Daniel may have a supernatural, albeit extremely flimsy, reason for loving Luce, but why does Luce love Daniel? He has shown zero interest in her. Oh wait. I remember. He’s gorgeous.
Not only that, but they’re not very interesting characters either. Luce and Daniel both have no personality, really. Daniel spends all his time feeling tortured and thinking, “Oh, Luce!” and Luce spends all her time being obsessive and thinking, “Oh Daniel!” These characters are like straight from the cheesiest romantic soap operas ever.
The plot … what plot? It was quite boring and slow. For 400 pages, I read about Luce admiring Daniel and how gorgeous he looks. I read about her stalking him. She’s annoyingly persistent. And then, finally, near the end, we have the scene that’s supposed to be the climax of the story — Daniel reveals his paranormal side (hint: the title of this book) — and we find out why he has been avoiding her the whole time. This climax was awful because any reader with half a brain could have pieced together the mystery of Daniel ages ago — not only does the title of this book provide a large clue, but the prologue and Daniel’s full name, Daniel Grigori does as well. It was like walking into a surprise party that you already knew about two weeks earlier.
The end of the book also kind of sets up the next book, but nothing is explained. For example, why is Luce so important that people want to kill her? Why is Cam evil? Why are Cam and Daniel fighting over Luce? Why are there so many of these paranormal creatures (I don’t want to spoil it even though it’s ridiculously easy to guess) gathered at Sword & Cross reform school? I know, I know — “It’ll be answered in the next book!” But to me, that is shoddy storytelling. Even if you are writing a series, each individual book must have a sense of resolution. As it is right now, Fallen feels like half a story. I know and understand nothing about its story world.
So, as you might gather by now, I didn’t like this book. It didn’t have much of a story, and mainly consisted of two overly dramatic, lovesick teenagers being obsessed with one another. And not in an entertaining Ron-and-Sammi-trainwreck kind of way.
(This book was from the library).
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Lauren Kate
Published: December 2009
Publisher: Doubleday
Series: Fallen #1
452 (paperback)
I have a weakness for books with beautiful covers, and Fallen has a very beautiful cover indeed. Except I don’t think the story inside the book lives up to the packaging. I am not even completely sure what I just read. After finishing the book, I am left with way too many questions, and I don’t feel like anything was really resolved … was there even anything to resolve? I got this book because the majority of my Goodreads friends gave it a high rating, but maybe I should have heeded the ratings of my non-friends more seriously. (Sorry, friends …)
If you’ve read Twilight, Hush Hush, Evermore, Elixir, Dead Beautiful, The Mephisto Covenant, (insert another YA paranormal romance here), you’ve read half this book already. Luce has been troubled by the black shadows she sees for years. She has been pretending she’s completely normal for years, until recently at a high school party, she may or may not have accidentally killed her crush in a fire. And we never find out more about that event because the point of all that is to give a reason for Luce to enter Sword & Cross, a reform school.
Right away, Luce spots Daniel Grigori, who is, of course, drop dead gorgeous, has a “muscled torso” (naturally; he wouldn’t be a very good YA paranormal romance male lead without one), and seems a bit tortured. Their relationship feels a lot like Bella and Edward — Luce performs some Insta-Love™. Daniel tries to stay away from Luce at first, and isn’t very nice to her. Daniel saves Luce from a falling statue, like Edward saved Bella from an incoming car. Luce is still attracted to Daniel despite his efforts to tell her to stay away for her own good. Luce decides to go all stalker-like and literally research Daniel by digging through his school files, using the Internet and looking up his ancestors.
Oh, and the entire time, Luce is pursued by another guy, who is equally good looking, called Cam. Cam actually shows interest in Luce, and expresses how fond of her he is and even buys her a necklace. But no, Luce wants the guy who is trying his best to ignore her. Seriously boggles my mind. (And yes, Cam turns out to be the antagonist. Why??)
At no point in the story did I understand why Luce and Daniel love one another. They just do. They’re soulmates. Daniel may have a supernatural, albeit extremely flimsy, reason for loving Luce, but why does Luce love Daniel? He has shown zero interest in her. Oh wait. I remember. He’s gorgeous.
Not only that, but they’re not very interesting characters either. Luce and Daniel both have no personality, really. Daniel spends all his time feeling tortured and thinking, “Oh, Luce!” and Luce spends all her time being obsessive and thinking, “Oh Daniel!” These characters are like straight from the cheesiest romantic soap operas ever.
The plot … what plot? It was quite boring and slow. For 400 pages, I read about Luce admiring Daniel and how gorgeous he looks. I read about her stalking him. She’s annoyingly persistent. And then, finally, near the end, we have the scene that’s supposed to be the climax of the story — Daniel reveals his paranormal side (hint: the title of this book) — and we find out why he has been avoiding her the whole time. This climax was awful because any reader with half a brain could have pieced together the mystery of Daniel ages ago — not only does the title of this book provide a large clue, but the prologue and Daniel’s full name, Daniel Grigori does as well. It was like walking into a surprise party that you already knew about two weeks earlier.
The end of the book also kind of sets up the next book, but nothing is explained. For example, why is Luce so important that people want to kill her? Why is Cam evil? Why are Cam and Daniel fighting over Luce? Why are there so many of these paranormal creatures (I don’t want to spoil it even though it’s ridiculously easy to guess) gathered at Sword & Cross reform school? I know, I know — “It’ll be answered in the next book!” But to me, that is shoddy storytelling. Even if you are writing a series, each individual book must have a sense of resolution. As it is right now, Fallen feels like half a story. I know and understand nothing about its story world.
So, as you might gather by now, I didn’t like this book. It didn’t have much of a story, and mainly consisted of two overly dramatic, lovesick teenagers being obsessed with one another. And not in an entertaining Ron-and-Sammi-trainwreck kind of way.
(This book was from the library).
My Rating: 1/5
The Mephisto Covenant
This post first published August 18, 2011.
Author: Trinity Faegen
Published: September 27, 2011
Publisher Egmont USA
Series: The Mephisto Covenant #1
448 pages (galley)
Where do I even begin?
I was originally super excited to read this book when I got it from NetGalley. There’s many positive reviews of it on Goodreads, and it had a very intriguing synopsis — Sasha, our main character, wants to know who murdered her father and thinks joining the cult, the Ravens, will bring her answers.
What she finds out instead is that she is Anabo, a descendant of Eve’s daughter (as in, Adam and Eve), and the Ravens try to kill her for it. The Ravens are working for Eryx, who is worse than Lucifer the Devil; Eryx is trying to use his recruited souls to power himself into overtaking Hell and Heaven. Sasha is saved, however, by Jax, who is a Son of Hell and is looking for his Anabo, his soulmate, who could lead him to a chance to be in Heaven.
This book is probably going to be popular amongst those who enjoy romances between super hot paranormal male leads and she-doesn’t-know-she’s-beautiful-and-special female leads, who, for one reason or another, are in angst for much of the story because they cannot be together. If you like that kind of story, you’ll love this — but The Mephisto Covenant was not my cup of tea at all, was not what I expected.
The story flowed awkwardly, was simply bizarre at times and the bit about finding out who murdered Sasha’s father was quickly resolved and thrown out the window after the first dozen pages. A majority of the scenes and dialogue are question-answer sessions between Sasha and the other characters, who dump a ton of background information on her (and the reader). And then there’s the strangeness of this Eyrx character who is more evil than Lucifer. Seriously, Lucifer and God are actually kind of working together as partners in this book, to bring down Eyrx who is the real kingpin of evil. I found that really hard to accept. Not that I’m religious or anything. It’s just the idea that the Devil himself is less evil than Eyrx doesn’t make sense to me.
On a similar note, Eryx isn’t even aware of Sasha’s existence for the vast majority of the novel, so I didn’t feel like there was much tension in the story. The stakes didn’t feel that high to me. Most of the story consisted of the characters worrying that Eyrx would discover Sasha the Anabo, and trying to keep Sasha safe from the enemy who doesn’t even know she exists yet.
However, the main focus of this story is the angsty romance between Sasha and Jax, which annoyed me way more than I found romantic. In fact, I don’t think any part of their relationship was romantic at all. There was insta-love, creepy-obsessive love and it was kind of shallow that all they ever talked about was how hot each other was. And there was a lot of focus on sex. Sex, sex, sex. All the characters, not just Sasha and Jax, but especially Sasha and Jax. It was drilled into my head how dangerous it would be if they had sex, and how Jax was so obsessed with seeing her naked. There was also a cliche ‘I almost got raped but my soulmate rescued me before it happened’ scene that I’ve read in a dozen YA novels now.
Then there’s the characters themselves, mainly Sasha and Jax. Jax was an overly protective, overly jealous, bordering-on-obsessive kind of boyfriend. Sasha spent most of her time crying in this novel, or feeling like she’s about to cry — sometimes over the silliest things, like getting a new laptop. I just wanted to reach into the pages, give the girl a good shake by the shoulders and exclaim, “Get a grip on yourself!”
I have an entire page of notes I scribbled down while reading this book, but I won’t get into them all. I can see this book being quite popular because I know there is an audience for stories like this, but this really wasn’t for me at all.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Trinity Faegen
Published: September 27, 2011
Publisher Egmont USA
Series: The Mephisto Covenant #1
448 pages (galley)
Where do I even begin?
I was originally super excited to read this book when I got it from NetGalley. There’s many positive reviews of it on Goodreads, and it had a very intriguing synopsis — Sasha, our main character, wants to know who murdered her father and thinks joining the cult, the Ravens, will bring her answers.
What she finds out instead is that she is Anabo, a descendant of Eve’s daughter (as in, Adam and Eve), and the Ravens try to kill her for it. The Ravens are working for Eryx, who is worse than Lucifer the Devil; Eryx is trying to use his recruited souls to power himself into overtaking Hell and Heaven. Sasha is saved, however, by Jax, who is a Son of Hell and is looking for his Anabo, his soulmate, who could lead him to a chance to be in Heaven.
This book is probably going to be popular amongst those who enjoy romances between super hot paranormal male leads and she-doesn’t-know-she’s-beautiful-and-special female leads, who, for one reason or another, are in angst for much of the story because they cannot be together. If you like that kind of story, you’ll love this — but The Mephisto Covenant was not my cup of tea at all, was not what I expected.
The story flowed awkwardly, was simply bizarre at times and the bit about finding out who murdered Sasha’s father was quickly resolved and thrown out the window after the first dozen pages. A majority of the scenes and dialogue are question-answer sessions between Sasha and the other characters, who dump a ton of background information on her (and the reader). And then there’s the strangeness of this Eyrx character who is more evil than Lucifer. Seriously, Lucifer and God are actually kind of working together as partners in this book, to bring down Eyrx who is the real kingpin of evil. I found that really hard to accept. Not that I’m religious or anything. It’s just the idea that the Devil himself is less evil than Eyrx doesn’t make sense to me.
On a similar note, Eryx isn’t even aware of Sasha’s existence for the vast majority of the novel, so I didn’t feel like there was much tension in the story. The stakes didn’t feel that high to me. Most of the story consisted of the characters worrying that Eyrx would discover Sasha the Anabo, and trying to keep Sasha safe from the enemy who doesn’t even know she exists yet.
However, the main focus of this story is the angsty romance between Sasha and Jax, which annoyed me way more than I found romantic. In fact, I don’t think any part of their relationship was romantic at all. There was insta-love, creepy-obsessive love and it was kind of shallow that all they ever talked about was how hot each other was. And there was a lot of focus on sex. Sex, sex, sex. All the characters, not just Sasha and Jax, but especially Sasha and Jax. It was drilled into my head how dangerous it would be if they had sex, and how Jax was so obsessed with seeing her naked. There was also a cliche ‘I almost got raped but my soulmate rescued me before it happened’ scene that I’ve read in a dozen YA novels now.
Then there’s the characters themselves, mainly Sasha and Jax. Jax was an overly protective, overly jealous, bordering-on-obsessive kind of boyfriend. Sasha spent most of her time crying in this novel, or feeling like she’s about to cry — sometimes over the silliest things, like getting a new laptop. I just wanted to reach into the pages, give the girl a good shake by the shoulders and exclaim, “Get a grip on yourself!”
I have an entire page of notes I scribbled down while reading this book, but I won’t get into them all. I can see this book being quite popular because I know there is an audience for stories like this, but this really wasn’t for me at all.
My Rating: 1/5
Labels:
1,
paranormal,
romance urban fantasy,
Trinity Faegen,
young adult
Possession
This post first published July 5, 2011.
Author: Elana Johnson
Published: June 2011
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing
Series: Possession #1
416 pages (eBook)
I’m on a YA streak. Expect more YA book blog posts in the near future.
I read this book on PulseIt, which is kind of like an S&S YA book club. I was lured in by the gorgeous cover — a simple white background with a butterfly trapped in an ice cube and the words ‘Control or Be Controlled’ at the top. Very mysterious, in a good way. Unfortunately, this is an example of that old saying Don’t judge a book by its cover, because the book didn’t live up to its gorgeous cover at all.
The story is about Violet, called Vi by everyone. She lives in a place called the Goodgrounds, where all the people are called Goodies. They are ruled by the Thinkers, who make everyone’s decisions for them so that they don’t have to, to keep everyone in check. Vi is the rebellious sort though, and resists their brainwashing. After many a rule-breaking, the last being seeing her boyfriend Zenn (boys and girls can’t be left alone together), Vi is sent to jail while they decide what to do with her. The Thinkers think about sending her to the Badlands where the Baddies live, something that scares Vi at first. That is, until she meets her jail cellmate, Jag Barque.
(And here is where I started raising my eyebrow — girls and boys can’t be alone together but they stick her in a jail cell with a guy? When there were plenty of empty cells available? I know because Vi pondered this as well, but could not come up with an explanation and it is never answered in the book).
Jag intrigues and even scares Vi a bit at first because he is a Baddie, and she has been taught all her life that Baddies are, well, bad. However, she quickly falls in love with him and they bust out of jail together, where they try to go to the Badlands. Vi discovers that Jag is a part of a rebel faction that is trying to break free of the Thinkers’ control. The Thinkers are desperate to have Vi and Jag on their side because it turns out they have mind controlling abilities, abilities that would make the Thinkers even more powerful than they already are.
I thought the plot sounded fantastic on paper. Sounds exciting, kind of Big Brother-ish, and probably action-packed as well. While it does have these elements, the book felt more like one confusing mess more than anything else. The actual result was like all these fantastic ideas got thrown together haphazardly, making the storyline feel kind of disjointed. A lot of the time I wasn’t even sure what place the characters were in because not only do they move around a LOT, but it their surroundings are not described. Sometimes, I don’t even know where they are at all, which was the case with the last scene. I had to make a lot of assumptions.
The characters were problematic as well. I didn’t like or dislike any of them. They were kind of just … there. That’s a problem in a story such as this. There’s a lot of shocks and twists in this book, but they didn’t have their desired effect because I simply didn’t care about the characters. I didn’t feel anxious when they were being chased, I didn’t feel shocked when Vi discovers the truth behind her father, I didn’t feel giddy when Jag and Vi kissed, I didn’t feel sad when Zenn turned out to be a not-so-good guy.
Vi, the protagonist, annoyed me more than anything. She’s whiny and makes a big deal about nothing a lot of the time. She also talks about how in love she is with Zenn at the beginning, but in the blink of an eye, falls in love with Jag. Then she pretends she still has feelings about Zenn, but who is she kidding? It’s so obvious that her feelings for Zenn were dropped the moment she met Jag. I don’t get the relationship between Vi and Jag either. It felt very forced. There is no rhyme or reason why they would fall in love. It seems to me they are just physically attracted to each other. Yet about halfway through the book, they are already convinced they cannot live without one another, despite only knowing one another for a week.
I didn’t like this book at all. I contemplated giving up on it around the halfway point because, while I understood what was happening, I didn’t understand why it was happening. The story world was so sloppily built, and the plot just careened along without a care for logic, rhyme or reason. The only reason I finished this book was because I’m one of those people who can’t stand leaving half-finished books laying around, it would drive me nuts.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Elana Johnson
Published: June 2011
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing
Series: Possession #1
416 pages (eBook)
I’m on a YA streak. Expect more YA book blog posts in the near future.
I read this book on PulseIt, which is kind of like an S&S YA book club. I was lured in by the gorgeous cover — a simple white background with a butterfly trapped in an ice cube and the words ‘Control or Be Controlled’ at the top. Very mysterious, in a good way. Unfortunately, this is an example of that old saying Don’t judge a book by its cover, because the book didn’t live up to its gorgeous cover at all.
The story is about Violet, called Vi by everyone. She lives in a place called the Goodgrounds, where all the people are called Goodies. They are ruled by the Thinkers, who make everyone’s decisions for them so that they don’t have to, to keep everyone in check. Vi is the rebellious sort though, and resists their brainwashing. After many a rule-breaking, the last being seeing her boyfriend Zenn (boys and girls can’t be left alone together), Vi is sent to jail while they decide what to do with her. The Thinkers think about sending her to the Badlands where the Baddies live, something that scares Vi at first. That is, until she meets her jail cellmate, Jag Barque.
(And here is where I started raising my eyebrow — girls and boys can’t be alone together but they stick her in a jail cell with a guy? When there were plenty of empty cells available? I know because Vi pondered this as well, but could not come up with an explanation and it is never answered in the book).
Jag intrigues and even scares Vi a bit at first because he is a Baddie, and she has been taught all her life that Baddies are, well, bad. However, she quickly falls in love with him and they bust out of jail together, where they try to go to the Badlands. Vi discovers that Jag is a part of a rebel faction that is trying to break free of the Thinkers’ control. The Thinkers are desperate to have Vi and Jag on their side because it turns out they have mind controlling abilities, abilities that would make the Thinkers even more powerful than they already are.
I thought the plot sounded fantastic on paper. Sounds exciting, kind of Big Brother-ish, and probably action-packed as well. While it does have these elements, the book felt more like one confusing mess more than anything else. The actual result was like all these fantastic ideas got thrown together haphazardly, making the storyline feel kind of disjointed. A lot of the time I wasn’t even sure what place the characters were in because not only do they move around a LOT, but it their surroundings are not described. Sometimes, I don’t even know where they are at all, which was the case with the last scene. I had to make a lot of assumptions.
The characters were problematic as well. I didn’t like or dislike any of them. They were kind of just … there. That’s a problem in a story such as this. There’s a lot of shocks and twists in this book, but they didn’t have their desired effect because I simply didn’t care about the characters. I didn’t feel anxious when they were being chased, I didn’t feel shocked when Vi discovers the truth behind her father, I didn’t feel giddy when Jag and Vi kissed, I didn’t feel sad when Zenn turned out to be a not-so-good guy.
Vi, the protagonist, annoyed me more than anything. She’s whiny and makes a big deal about nothing a lot of the time. She also talks about how in love she is with Zenn at the beginning, but in the blink of an eye, falls in love with Jag. Then she pretends she still has feelings about Zenn, but who is she kidding? It’s so obvious that her feelings for Zenn were dropped the moment she met Jag. I don’t get the relationship between Vi and Jag either. It felt very forced. There is no rhyme or reason why they would fall in love. It seems to me they are just physically attracted to each other. Yet about halfway through the book, they are already convinced they cannot live without one another, despite only knowing one another for a week.
I didn’t like this book at all. I contemplated giving up on it around the halfway point because, while I understood what was happening, I didn’t understand why it was happening. The story world was so sloppily built, and the plot just careened along without a care for logic, rhyme or reason. The only reason I finished this book was because I’m one of those people who can’t stand leaving half-finished books laying around, it would drive me nuts.
My Rating: 1/5
Eragon
This post first published June 16, 2011.
Author: Christopher Paolini
Published: 2002
Publisher: Laurel Leaf
Series: Inheritance #1
730 pages (mass market paperback)
I remember eight or nine years ago, seeing this book everywhere in bookshops and there was the movie and everything too. I didn’t get around to reading it then, but I picked it up now because I know someone who likes this series so when I saw it, by chance, at the library, I decided to take it out.
An elf named Arya is trying to smuggle a dragon’s egg to a safe location, away from the evil Empire. When it seems they are about to catch her, she uses magic to make the egg appear leagues away, in front of a boy named Eragon, who thinks he’s found a polished blue stone. Eragon is a realtively normal fifteen year old kid, living on a farm, but his life is turned upside down when he realizes the Empire is trying to find this mysterious stone (that he later realizes is a dragon’s egg). After the Empire burns down his farm, killing his uncle in the process, Eragon flees while vowing to get revenge. He is found by an old storyteller named Brom, who turns out not to be who he is — he is actually part of an ancient order of Riders, men who had dragons and rode the skies protecting the land. With Brom on his side, Eragon journeys to where he believes the killers are, while being taught swordplay and magic.
There’s more, but if you haven’t noticed by now, you just read the basic plot of Star Wars: Episode IV. The rest of the book is also quite similar to the ending of Star Wars, but since I didn’t want to give away “spoilers”, I didn’t continue describing the plot (which is, I know, silly, if you already know the plot of Star Wars).
Eragon is written by then-teenager Christopher Paolini, and all I can say is that it really shows. I couldn’t stand the writing and I’m certain there was some thesaurus abuse. He over-describes everything, every room, every piece of clothing, every action. This also applies to the general story: every little action was described. He doesn’t take advantage of the fact that words can make the passing of time go much faster or slower — you’re just stuck with Eragon the whole time in everything he does. An entire chapter is devoted to describing an eventless trip through the desert, which I think could have been summed up in a paragraph, if not a sentence or two. I remember there was a scene where Eragon is talking to someone, mentions he’s feeling a little grimy from all his traveling, so he goes takes a bath, and comes back to resume the conversation. I mean, really? Did you have to insert a bath scene right then? It didn’t add anything to the story at all. It was utterly pointless.
The characters were rather boring. Eragon started out bland and one dimensional, and as the story continued, I actually started disliking him. Other characters scraped by with maybe two character traits. For the majority of the book, the characters were very evenly split into good guys versus bad guys, with no gray area. Such black and white characters. There was a little bit of an attempt to give Durza, one of the main villains, a sympathizing back story near the very end of the novel, but it was done rather clumsily and hastily, so it didn’t really work. As for the races, they were incredibly cliche: elegant, beautiful and wise elves; short, strong, hardy dwarves; young, ambitious humans. Yeah.
Move along, nothing new here.
I’ve no doubt that the author put lots of time and effort into this book, as all authors do, and I don’t think the similarities to Star Wars are intentional, but I can’t help but wonder how this book became as popular as it did. My overall experience with Eragon was cringe-worthy. I spent the last 200-ish pages wondering why this story just won’t end. I definitely have no interest in continuing this series.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Christopher Paolini
Published: 2002
Publisher: Laurel Leaf
Series: Inheritance #1
730 pages (mass market paperback)
I remember eight or nine years ago, seeing this book everywhere in bookshops and there was the movie and everything too. I didn’t get around to reading it then, but I picked it up now because I know someone who likes this series so when I saw it, by chance, at the library, I decided to take it out.
An elf named Arya is trying to smuggle a dragon’s egg to a safe location, away from the evil Empire. When it seems they are about to catch her, she uses magic to make the egg appear leagues away, in front of a boy named Eragon, who thinks he’s found a polished blue stone. Eragon is a realtively normal fifteen year old kid, living on a farm, but his life is turned upside down when he realizes the Empire is trying to find this mysterious stone (that he later realizes is a dragon’s egg). After the Empire burns down his farm, killing his uncle in the process, Eragon flees while vowing to get revenge. He is found by an old storyteller named Brom, who turns out not to be who he is — he is actually part of an ancient order of Riders, men who had dragons and rode the skies protecting the land. With Brom on his side, Eragon journeys to where he believes the killers are, while being taught swordplay and magic.
There’s more, but if you haven’t noticed by now, you just read the basic plot of Star Wars: Episode IV. The rest of the book is also quite similar to the ending of Star Wars, but since I didn’t want to give away “spoilers”, I didn’t continue describing the plot (which is, I know, silly, if you already know the plot of Star Wars).
Eragon is written by then-teenager Christopher Paolini, and all I can say is that it really shows. I couldn’t stand the writing and I’m certain there was some thesaurus abuse. He over-describes everything, every room, every piece of clothing, every action. This also applies to the general story: every little action was described. He doesn’t take advantage of the fact that words can make the passing of time go much faster or slower — you’re just stuck with Eragon the whole time in everything he does. An entire chapter is devoted to describing an eventless trip through the desert, which I think could have been summed up in a paragraph, if not a sentence or two. I remember there was a scene where Eragon is talking to someone, mentions he’s feeling a little grimy from all his traveling, so he goes takes a bath, and comes back to resume the conversation. I mean, really? Did you have to insert a bath scene right then? It didn’t add anything to the story at all. It was utterly pointless.
The characters were rather boring. Eragon started out bland and one dimensional, and as the story continued, I actually started disliking him. Other characters scraped by with maybe two character traits. For the majority of the book, the characters were very evenly split into good guys versus bad guys, with no gray area. Such black and white characters. There was a little bit of an attempt to give Durza, one of the main villains, a sympathizing back story near the very end of the novel, but it was done rather clumsily and hastily, so it didn’t really work. As for the races, they were incredibly cliche: elegant, beautiful and wise elves; short, strong, hardy dwarves; young, ambitious humans. Yeah.
Move along, nothing new here.
I’ve no doubt that the author put lots of time and effort into this book, as all authors do, and I don’t think the similarities to Star Wars are intentional, but I can’t help but wonder how this book became as popular as it did. My overall experience with Eragon was cringe-worthy. I spent the last 200-ish pages wondering why this story just won’t end. I definitely have no interest in continuing this series.
My Rating: 1/5
Labels:
1,
christopher paolini,
epic fantasy,
fantasy,
young adult
Wednesday, September 30, 2015
Pegasus
This post first published May 7, 2011.
Author: Robin McKinley
Published: November 2010
Publisher: Putnam Juvenile
404 pages (hardcover)
I love Robin McKinley. She’s amazing at retelling fairy tales, and some of my favourite books of her’s includes Spindle’s End, Rose Daughter and Beauty. So when I saw Pegasus sitting in the new books section of my library, I picked it up without a second thought. Unfortunately, I was horribly, horribly disappointed with this book … I felt so let down. It’s Robin McKinley! I thought I was in for a real stellar story but I got … the opposite of a stellar story.
The premise sounds interesting enough (if not slightly odd): in this world, pegasi are a ‘people’ — they are just as intelligent as people and they have their own mini-civilization and everything. There’s a pegasus king and a pegasus queen, and they have pegasus princes and princesses. There are pegasus shamans and sculptors and servants and, well, ‘regular people’. They have buildings, they can do crafts and make paper and bags and … well, you get the idea.
In this world, the royal humans are bound to a pegasus; not like pets or anything, oh no! This binding or bonding is an ancient tradition from centuries ago when the Alliance formed between the humans and the pegasi. Anyway, the main character of this novel is Sylvi, and the story begins with her being afraid of her bonding ceremony to her pegasus, Ebon. The rest of the plot can be really easily summarized: Sylvi and Ebon realize they can actually mind-speak with one another and become super good buddies, which freaks out one of the human magicians, Fthoom, because this is not supposed to happen and he’s convinced that such a bond will bring disaster to their Alliance. At one point, Ebon invites Sylvi to visit him in his pegasus country. She goes, a change happens to her in that she feels more connected to the pegasi than ever. (!!! sort of spoiler-ish but I really don’t think so !!!) She comes back to the human country where rocs and other intelligent monster bird creatures are preparing to attack their country, at the same time Fthoom finds evidence that Sylvi and Ebon’s relationship really is disastrous for their countries. (!!! end spoilers !!!)
The plot moved so slow. It was, for lack of a better word, boring. I could not comfortably read this book in a sitting or two — small doses is what got me through it. I felt like often the narration beats around the bush, repeating things that have already been driven into my head multiple times earlier, and is just … slow. The first half of the novel is mostly just explaining the world of the pegasus, and a lot of background information regarding the Alliance and how it came to be.
The last 30% of the novel, according to some reviewers on Goodreads, is more action-filled and gripping, but I did not find it that way, personally. The entire thing, from beginning to end, was sluggish. I don’t know what action those reviewers were referring to; I didn’t find any. I don’t know if I even experienced the climax of the story. I’m not even really sure what the conflict is, or was. And the ending was really sudden. It’s a cliffhanger, which surely means there’s a sequel coming soon (which, at this moment, I don’t plan on reading). It didn’t even really feel like a cliffhanger, it just felt like the story abruptly ended, in a place it shouldn’t have. I feel that, since this entire book felt like one big Pegasus 101 textbook, the sequel should have just been merged into this book to make one book. There’s no need for two books, because there pretty much nothing happened in this first book, so if there is actually a conflict or a plot in the second one that continues this story, I feel it should just have been all put together in one package.
That’s all just my personal opinion though. From what I can tell, it seems people are pretty split on this book. There are many who feel the way I do, but there are also some who felt Pegasus was an enjoyable read (though they agree the beginning, at least, was slow). Anyway, I don’t really recommend reading this book, especially if you want to try some of Robin McKinley’s work; she has so many better novels published, and Pegasus is not one of them.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Robin McKinley
Published: November 2010
Publisher: Putnam Juvenile
404 pages (hardcover)
I love Robin McKinley. She’s amazing at retelling fairy tales, and some of my favourite books of her’s includes Spindle’s End, Rose Daughter and Beauty. So when I saw Pegasus sitting in the new books section of my library, I picked it up without a second thought. Unfortunately, I was horribly, horribly disappointed with this book … I felt so let down. It’s Robin McKinley! I thought I was in for a real stellar story but I got … the opposite of a stellar story.
The premise sounds interesting enough (if not slightly odd): in this world, pegasi are a ‘people’ — they are just as intelligent as people and they have their own mini-civilization and everything. There’s a pegasus king and a pegasus queen, and they have pegasus princes and princesses. There are pegasus shamans and sculptors and servants and, well, ‘regular people’. They have buildings, they can do crafts and make paper and bags and … well, you get the idea.
In this world, the royal humans are bound to a pegasus; not like pets or anything, oh no! This binding or bonding is an ancient tradition from centuries ago when the Alliance formed between the humans and the pegasi. Anyway, the main character of this novel is Sylvi, and the story begins with her being afraid of her bonding ceremony to her pegasus, Ebon. The rest of the plot can be really easily summarized: Sylvi and Ebon realize they can actually mind-speak with one another and become super good buddies, which freaks out one of the human magicians, Fthoom, because this is not supposed to happen and he’s convinced that such a bond will bring disaster to their Alliance. At one point, Ebon invites Sylvi to visit him in his pegasus country. She goes, a change happens to her in that she feels more connected to the pegasi than ever. (!!! sort of spoiler-ish but I really don’t think so !!!) She comes back to the human country where rocs and other intelligent monster bird creatures are preparing to attack their country, at the same time Fthoom finds evidence that Sylvi and Ebon’s relationship really is disastrous for their countries. (!!! end spoilers !!!)
The plot moved so slow. It was, for lack of a better word, boring. I could not comfortably read this book in a sitting or two — small doses is what got me through it. I felt like often the narration beats around the bush, repeating things that have already been driven into my head multiple times earlier, and is just … slow. The first half of the novel is mostly just explaining the world of the pegasus, and a lot of background information regarding the Alliance and how it came to be.
The last 30% of the novel, according to some reviewers on Goodreads, is more action-filled and gripping, but I did not find it that way, personally. The entire thing, from beginning to end, was sluggish. I don’t know what action those reviewers were referring to; I didn’t find any. I don’t know if I even experienced the climax of the story. I’m not even really sure what the conflict is, or was. And the ending was really sudden. It’s a cliffhanger, which surely means there’s a sequel coming soon (which, at this moment, I don’t plan on reading). It didn’t even really feel like a cliffhanger, it just felt like the story abruptly ended, in a place it shouldn’t have. I feel that, since this entire book felt like one big Pegasus 101 textbook, the sequel should have just been merged into this book to make one book. There’s no need for two books, because there pretty much nothing happened in this first book, so if there is actually a conflict or a plot in the second one that continues this story, I feel it should just have been all put together in one package.
That’s all just my personal opinion though. From what I can tell, it seems people are pretty split on this book. There are many who feel the way I do, but there are also some who felt Pegasus was an enjoyable read (though they agree the beginning, at least, was slow). Anyway, I don’t really recommend reading this book, especially if you want to try some of Robin McKinley’s work; she has so many better novels published, and Pegasus is not one of them.
My Rating: 1/5
The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner
This post originally published September 29, 2010.
Author: Stephenie Meyer
Published: June 2009
Publisher: Little Brown Books for Young Readers
Series: Twilight series (companion book)
178 pages (hardcover)
First of all, I feel like I need to clarify my stance on the Twilight series of books. I loved Twilight, I liked New Moon and Eclipse (for the most part; Eclipse a little less) and I hated Breaking Dawn. I tell people I have a love-hate thing with Twilight, to keep it ‘simple’. Anyway, I wasn’t planning on reading this short novella, this companion piece to the series. For one, I was not interested in Bree Tanner. I barely remembered who she was, since she was the most minor of characters that popped up in Eclipse. Secondly, Breaking Dawn left a very bad taste in my mouth and I didn’t have much of a desire to continue the series in any way. However, when I saw this at the library, morbid curiosity got the better of me.
Bree is a newborn vampire created as a part of Victoria’s vampire army in book three, Eclipse. Bree’s only been a vampire for 3 months and has been doing her best to not attract attention or trouble in her coven of vampires, all of whom are newborns. Newborn vampires are driven by their thirst for human blood and seem to be predisposed to violence and havoc. Luckily for Bree, she manages to keep her vampire instincts controlled and uses fellow vampire Fred (who has the gift of making people not notice him or those around him; being invisible without actually turning invisible) to survive in her coven. She and her only friend in the coven, Diego, are becoming suspicious of their “boss” Riley and their creator, Victoria but are too afraid to really do anything about it.
The problem with this story is that it isn’t interesting. To quote my friend, “This book is, in a word, boring.” Bree isn’t a character anybody cared or even remembered about. The first half of the book was just plain boring. Bree meets Diego and they became super close friends in less than a day’s time, despite Bree telling the reader all about how guarded you have to be as a newborn vampire. Just because she got some good vibes with this Diego, she’s suddenly forming a BFF club with him (literally – I’m not making this up). Oh, and Bree falls in love with Diego (or at least a very big crush), and he with her. It isn’t stated, but it’s heavily implied. I didn’t feel as if a romantic relationship between them fit in this book at all. Anyway, they get trapped in an underwater cave at one point, trying to escape the sun, share some details about their human past and their suspicions about Riley. It was very ho-hum.
The second half of the book described the climatic fight that occurred in Eclipse, a fight readers already read about and know about, so there is nothing really new at all. Granted, it was through a different set of eyes (Bree’s), but Bree wasn’t even in the fight and spent most of her time hiding. (And I had to wonder how she didn’t see any werewolves in the fight. It’s been a long time since I last read Eclipse, but I did see the movie recently and I swear Bree was there while the werewolves were ripping apart the newborns. The werewolves are the best part too! (I’m on Team Werewolves, by the way)). At the very end, I found a disconnect between Bree’s narrator voice and her dialogue. The dialogue is straight from Eclipse and it just doesn’t match the Bree that we’ve become accustomed to during the course of the novel. For a book that is supposed to individualize Bree as a character, her narrating voice is actually exactly the same as Bella’s.
Only a Twilight fan could read this book, and even then, I think many Twilight fans will find themselves disappointed with this novel. No familiar characters (not until the very end, and it’s all scenes we’ve read about before), and just a recycling of plot for the most part. I understand that it’s supposed to tell Bree’s life up to the point she was killed — if you’ve read Eclipse, you already know she’s going to die by the end — but still, there are so many ways of going about this without simply recycling the scenes.
Overall, this book felt very underwhelming. It almost felt like it was written quickly and rushed to the printers to make a quick buck while everyone’s still in the Twilight frenzy. I needed something brilliant in the Twilight series to bring me back into it after the disaster that was Breaking Dawn but I am made to stay away from it all even more.
PS. Last thing – I was trying to figure out who the “red headed Cullen” was that was described in the book. Only until Bree mentioned him being a mind reader, I realized it was Edward. WTF Edward is not a redhead, or has Meyer forgotten what her characters look like??
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Stephenie Meyer
Published: June 2009
Publisher: Little Brown Books for Young Readers
Series: Twilight series (companion book)
178 pages (hardcover)
First of all, I feel like I need to clarify my stance on the Twilight series of books. I loved Twilight, I liked New Moon and Eclipse (for the most part; Eclipse a little less) and I hated Breaking Dawn. I tell people I have a love-hate thing with Twilight, to keep it ‘simple’. Anyway, I wasn’t planning on reading this short novella, this companion piece to the series. For one, I was not interested in Bree Tanner. I barely remembered who she was, since she was the most minor of characters that popped up in Eclipse. Secondly, Breaking Dawn left a very bad taste in my mouth and I didn’t have much of a desire to continue the series in any way. However, when I saw this at the library, morbid curiosity got the better of me.
Bree is a newborn vampire created as a part of Victoria’s vampire army in book three, Eclipse. Bree’s only been a vampire for 3 months and has been doing her best to not attract attention or trouble in her coven of vampires, all of whom are newborns. Newborn vampires are driven by their thirst for human blood and seem to be predisposed to violence and havoc. Luckily for Bree, she manages to keep her vampire instincts controlled and uses fellow vampire Fred (who has the gift of making people not notice him or those around him; being invisible without actually turning invisible) to survive in her coven. She and her only friend in the coven, Diego, are becoming suspicious of their “boss” Riley and their creator, Victoria but are too afraid to really do anything about it.
The problem with this story is that it isn’t interesting. To quote my friend, “This book is, in a word, boring.” Bree isn’t a character anybody cared or even remembered about. The first half of the book was just plain boring. Bree meets Diego and they became super close friends in less than a day’s time, despite Bree telling the reader all about how guarded you have to be as a newborn vampire. Just because she got some good vibes with this Diego, she’s suddenly forming a BFF club with him (literally – I’m not making this up). Oh, and Bree falls in love with Diego (or at least a very big crush), and he with her. It isn’t stated, but it’s heavily implied. I didn’t feel as if a romantic relationship between them fit in this book at all. Anyway, they get trapped in an underwater cave at one point, trying to escape the sun, share some details about their human past and their suspicions about Riley. It was very ho-hum.
The second half of the book described the climatic fight that occurred in Eclipse, a fight readers already read about and know about, so there is nothing really new at all. Granted, it was through a different set of eyes (Bree’s), but Bree wasn’t even in the fight and spent most of her time hiding. (And I had to wonder how she didn’t see any werewolves in the fight. It’s been a long time since I last read Eclipse, but I did see the movie recently and I swear Bree was there while the werewolves were ripping apart the newborns. The werewolves are the best part too! (I’m on Team Werewolves, by the way)). At the very end, I found a disconnect between Bree’s narrator voice and her dialogue. The dialogue is straight from Eclipse and it just doesn’t match the Bree that we’ve become accustomed to during the course of the novel. For a book that is supposed to individualize Bree as a character, her narrating voice is actually exactly the same as Bella’s.
Only a Twilight fan could read this book, and even then, I think many Twilight fans will find themselves disappointed with this novel. No familiar characters (not until the very end, and it’s all scenes we’ve read about before), and just a recycling of plot for the most part. I understand that it’s supposed to tell Bree’s life up to the point she was killed — if you’ve read Eclipse, you already know she’s going to die by the end — but still, there are so many ways of going about this without simply recycling the scenes.
Overall, this book felt very underwhelming. It almost felt like it was written quickly and rushed to the printers to make a quick buck while everyone’s still in the Twilight frenzy. I needed something brilliant in the Twilight series to bring me back into it after the disaster that was Breaking Dawn but I am made to stay away from it all even more.
PS. Last thing – I was trying to figure out who the “red headed Cullen” was that was described in the book. Only until Bree mentioned him being a mind reader, I realized it was Edward. WTF Edward is not a redhead, or has Meyer forgotten what her characters look like??
My Rating: 1/5
Last Chance For Paris
This post originally published August 10, 2010.
Author: Sylvia McNicoll
Published: November 2007
Publisher: Fitzhenry and Whiteside
204 pages (paperback)
Fourteen year old Zanna is “banished” to live with her father and twin brother, Martin, in Last Chance, Alberta while her father the professor conducts research on ice fields and glaciers. Her mother felt that Zanna’s newfound boyfriend Zane was controlling her, not to mention that she was furious over Zanna’s strawberry tattoo she got without permission, and hopes that a change of scenery will change Zanna’s perspective on things.
For Zanna, this is the worst summer vacation that could ever happen to her. Except to me, it’s really not that bad — most of the bad things that happen to Zanna are situations she created herself (such as her dumb decision to wade into the rapids and then getting swept away by the icy water, or deliberately ignoring her mother’s e-mails only to later realize that her mother was asking her to come to Paris, and then Zanna had the audacity to complain that it’s her mother’s fault that she missed the airplane seat sale). Zanna is a perfect representation of what a fourteen year old adolescent is like; unfortunately, this means she is self centered, incredibly whiny and very hard to like. She’s also seems to suffer from the delusion that she and her boyfriend of a few weeks will last ‘forever’. Anyway, I did not like Zanna or her special snowflake name.
For a young adult novel, I expected more than bare and minimal writing, but as it is right now, I’ve read children’s novels with more complex writing than this book. I was also not fond of the story. It was, for lack of better words, incredibly boring. The reason it took me so long to finish a mere 200 pages is because I did not like it and had to force myself to finish it, something that I could not do all in one sitting.
Things are supposed to pick up a bit more when Zanna finds the “puppy” under her deck and meets Tyler the park ranger (who she obviously starts liking; this novel is incredibly predictable), but it didn’t really. The climax of the novel is when Martin disappears, leaving Zanna and Tyler to search for him in the wild. That part was a little more interesting in comparison to the rest of the novel, but it was still the dullest search and rescue story I’ve ever read. At the end of the novel, Zanna is supposed to have experienced a change and see herself differently, but the ONLY realizations she makes is that her boyfriend is a jerk and her mom sucks being a mom; not exactly life-changing.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Sylvia McNicoll
Published: November 2007
Publisher: Fitzhenry and Whiteside
204 pages (paperback)
Fourteen year old Zanna is “banished” to live with her father and twin brother, Martin, in Last Chance, Alberta while her father the professor conducts research on ice fields and glaciers. Her mother felt that Zanna’s newfound boyfriend Zane was controlling her, not to mention that she was furious over Zanna’s strawberry tattoo she got without permission, and hopes that a change of scenery will change Zanna’s perspective on things.
For Zanna, this is the worst summer vacation that could ever happen to her. Except to me, it’s really not that bad — most of the bad things that happen to Zanna are situations she created herself (such as her dumb decision to wade into the rapids and then getting swept away by the icy water, or deliberately ignoring her mother’s e-mails only to later realize that her mother was asking her to come to Paris, and then Zanna had the audacity to complain that it’s her mother’s fault that she missed the airplane seat sale). Zanna is a perfect representation of what a fourteen year old adolescent is like; unfortunately, this means she is self centered, incredibly whiny and very hard to like. She’s also seems to suffer from the delusion that she and her boyfriend of a few weeks will last ‘forever’. Anyway, I did not like Zanna or her special snowflake name.
For a young adult novel, I expected more than bare and minimal writing, but as it is right now, I’ve read children’s novels with more complex writing than this book. I was also not fond of the story. It was, for lack of better words, incredibly boring. The reason it took me so long to finish a mere 200 pages is because I did not like it and had to force myself to finish it, something that I could not do all in one sitting.
Things are supposed to pick up a bit more when Zanna finds the “puppy” under her deck and meets Tyler the park ranger (who she obviously starts liking; this novel is incredibly predictable), but it didn’t really. The climax of the novel is when Martin disappears, leaving Zanna and Tyler to search for him in the wild. That part was a little more interesting in comparison to the rest of the novel, but it was still the dullest search and rescue story I’ve ever read. At the end of the novel, Zanna is supposed to have experienced a change and see herself differently, but the ONLY realizations she makes is that her boyfriend is a jerk and her mom sucks being a mom; not exactly life-changing.
My Rating: 1/5
Jazz
This post originally published January 23, 2010.
Author: Toni Morrison
Published: 1992
Publisher: Vintage
229 pages (paperback)
Summary: A story about black urban life, set in the 1920’s in a place referred to as the City (Harlem), the main story revolves around three people: Joe is a 50 year old door-to-door cosmetic salesman; Violet is Joe’s wife and an unlicensed hairdresser; and Dorca is a young teenage girl who Joe is having an affair with. In a fury of passion, confusion and agonizing love, Joe shoots Dorca to death, and cries for months afterwards in regret. Violet shows up at Dorca’s funeral and attempts to slice the dead girl’s face with a knife, but fails. Wanting to understand the situation, and to know more about Dorca, Violet seeks out Dorca’s aunt, Alice Manfred and befriends her.
My Thoughts: A book I had to read for my American Literature class. The back cover of the book has a similar summary to the one I typed up there (except I think I added more descriptions about the plot since the book’s summary was rather vague). Anyway, the plot summary sounded interesting at first, and hey, it says this book won a Nobel Prize in Literature, so I thought it must be good. But truth be told, I found the whole thing boring. If you look at the book as a piece of artwork, then yes, it is excellent, and that’s probably why my class is reading and analyzing this book. But as entertainment, or for leisurely reading? Not so much. It’s like looking at a famous painting — I can appreciate the complexity of it and the meaning behind it, but that doesn’t mean I like it and want to hang it in my living room.
It was just too difficult of a read for me. I don’t mean the language the books uses, but the way the scenes shift so quickly, and nothing seems to happen chronologically, which wouldn’t be the end of the world if I could make sense of it still. The story is not really about the plot, but about the characters and their fears, passions, obsessions, insecurities. It explains their whole back stories, and then in the last half of the book, it explained the lives of Joe’s mother and Violet’s grandmother and even Violet’s grandmother’s boss’s daughter’s son! It was all very confusing to be honest, and the shift from character to character is so abrupt I often missed it. After I finished the book, I read a chapter-by-chapter summary of the novel online because I was so confused, and the strange thing is, the summary outlined everything I already knew, so I guess, I DID understand what I was reading, I just couldn’t make sense of it, which really hindered me from enjoying it.
Not really much I can say about it. I don’t think this novel sucks by any means, but it’s certainly not fun to read. I’m glad it was only 229 pages because if it was any longer, I don’t know if I could have finished it.
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Toni Morrison
Published: 1992
Publisher: Vintage
229 pages (paperback)
Summary: A story about black urban life, set in the 1920’s in a place referred to as the City (Harlem), the main story revolves around three people: Joe is a 50 year old door-to-door cosmetic salesman; Violet is Joe’s wife and an unlicensed hairdresser; and Dorca is a young teenage girl who Joe is having an affair with. In a fury of passion, confusion and agonizing love, Joe shoots Dorca to death, and cries for months afterwards in regret. Violet shows up at Dorca’s funeral and attempts to slice the dead girl’s face with a knife, but fails. Wanting to understand the situation, and to know more about Dorca, Violet seeks out Dorca’s aunt, Alice Manfred and befriends her.
My Thoughts: A book I had to read for my American Literature class. The back cover of the book has a similar summary to the one I typed up there (except I think I added more descriptions about the plot since the book’s summary was rather vague). Anyway, the plot summary sounded interesting at first, and hey, it says this book won a Nobel Prize in Literature, so I thought it must be good. But truth be told, I found the whole thing boring. If you look at the book as a piece of artwork, then yes, it is excellent, and that’s probably why my class is reading and analyzing this book. But as entertainment, or for leisurely reading? Not so much. It’s like looking at a famous painting — I can appreciate the complexity of it and the meaning behind it, but that doesn’t mean I like it and want to hang it in my living room.
It was just too difficult of a read for me. I don’t mean the language the books uses, but the way the scenes shift so quickly, and nothing seems to happen chronologically, which wouldn’t be the end of the world if I could make sense of it still. The story is not really about the plot, but about the characters and their fears, passions, obsessions, insecurities. It explains their whole back stories, and then in the last half of the book, it explained the lives of Joe’s mother and Violet’s grandmother and even Violet’s grandmother’s boss’s daughter’s son! It was all very confusing to be honest, and the shift from character to character is so abrupt I often missed it. After I finished the book, I read a chapter-by-chapter summary of the novel online because I was so confused, and the strange thing is, the summary outlined everything I already knew, so I guess, I DID understand what I was reading, I just couldn’t make sense of it, which really hindered me from enjoying it.
Not really much I can say about it. I don’t think this novel sucks by any means, but it’s certainly not fun to read. I’m glad it was only 229 pages because if it was any longer, I don’t know if I could have finished it.
My Rating: 1/5
Green Grass, Running Water
This post originally published January 13, 2010.
Author: Thomas King
Published: 1993
Publisher: Harper Perennial
480 pages (paperback)
Synopsis: The story begins with Coyote and an unknown narrator in conversation. A dream of Coyote’s has taken a life of its own, running around and proclaiming itself GOD, but Coyote laughs and tells him he is not GOD, but a Dog. Dog wants to know why there is water everywhere, and the unknown narrator begins to explain by telling them both about four Indians (as they are called; they are Native Americans) who have escaped from a mental institution. The people at the hospital are searching for them; it is not the first time they have escaped. As the four Indians plan on how they will fix the world, their paths follow and intersect with a whole platoon of other Native American characters who are searching for their identity between their traditions and the modern world.
My Thoughts: Another novel I had to read, for my Canadian Literature course. It was really hard to write a synopsis for this story because, well, even by the end of the novel, I wasn’t really sure what the story was about. I think this novel is a comparison between Native American traditions, lifestyle and beliefs with Western ones, as evident by the creation story that unfolds — the narrator tells a story about what I assume to be famous Native American figures who take on the names of famous Western characters (The Lone Ranger, Ishmael, Hawkeye and Robinson Crusoe). These characters each encounter a bizarre and comical situation with a biblical/Christian character such as Jesus, or Noah, etc. It uses satire to compare the two beliefs.
This book is described as brilliant writing, has received rave reviews and has the honor of being one of the best Canadian novels of all time. I don’t doubt any of that at all, I can sort of see why one would regard this novel highly, but to be quite honest, I personally found this book terribly boring. I guess this is more of a book club discussion or college literature course type of book, not something I felt that can be read leisurely. The unique story structure and intertwining plots were confusing for me and I didn’t like any of the characters. There are a ton of characters in this novel and they all know one another in some way (sort of the same way the characters in the movies Love Actually or He’s Just Not That Into You do). All the characters had their own individual stories going on and I understood how they related to one another, but I didn’t understand the role of the four escaped Indians, and I didn’t understand the role of the unknown narrator or Coyote, and how the story of how the world was created fit in with all of this. I suspect there’s something symbolic or that there’s a deep meaning somewhere, but I only understood the surface of the story, to be honest — Native Americans were trying to maintain their traditions while living side by side with the modern world, and some Native Americans forsaking their traditions altogether and assimilating. I just didn’t understand the story and the parts I did understand, I didn’t find interesting. I always feel a bit ‘guilty’ when I say I don’t like books that other people regard as modern classics, or books that everyone but myself seem to love, so it kind of hurts to give it just one star (with a reminder that to me, one star just means I didn’t like it, not necessarily an awful book) though that’s just me — maybe you’ll find it more interesting than I did (apparently lots of people do, haha).
My Rating: 1/5
Author: Thomas King
Published: 1993
Publisher: Harper Perennial
480 pages (paperback)
Synopsis: The story begins with Coyote and an unknown narrator in conversation. A dream of Coyote’s has taken a life of its own, running around and proclaiming itself GOD, but Coyote laughs and tells him he is not GOD, but a Dog. Dog wants to know why there is water everywhere, and the unknown narrator begins to explain by telling them both about four Indians (as they are called; they are Native Americans) who have escaped from a mental institution. The people at the hospital are searching for them; it is not the first time they have escaped. As the four Indians plan on how they will fix the world, their paths follow and intersect with a whole platoon of other Native American characters who are searching for their identity between their traditions and the modern world.
My Thoughts: Another novel I had to read, for my Canadian Literature course. It was really hard to write a synopsis for this story because, well, even by the end of the novel, I wasn’t really sure what the story was about. I think this novel is a comparison between Native American traditions, lifestyle and beliefs with Western ones, as evident by the creation story that unfolds — the narrator tells a story about what I assume to be famous Native American figures who take on the names of famous Western characters (The Lone Ranger, Ishmael, Hawkeye and Robinson Crusoe). These characters each encounter a bizarre and comical situation with a biblical/Christian character such as Jesus, or Noah, etc. It uses satire to compare the two beliefs.
This book is described as brilliant writing, has received rave reviews and has the honor of being one of the best Canadian novels of all time. I don’t doubt any of that at all, I can sort of see why one would regard this novel highly, but to be quite honest, I personally found this book terribly boring. I guess this is more of a book club discussion or college literature course type of book, not something I felt that can be read leisurely. The unique story structure and intertwining plots were confusing for me and I didn’t like any of the characters. There are a ton of characters in this novel and they all know one another in some way (sort of the same way the characters in the movies Love Actually or He’s Just Not That Into You do). All the characters had their own individual stories going on and I understood how they related to one another, but I didn’t understand the role of the four escaped Indians, and I didn’t understand the role of the unknown narrator or Coyote, and how the story of how the world was created fit in with all of this. I suspect there’s something symbolic or that there’s a deep meaning somewhere, but I only understood the surface of the story, to be honest — Native Americans were trying to maintain their traditions while living side by side with the modern world, and some Native Americans forsaking their traditions altogether and assimilating. I just didn’t understand the story and the parts I did understand, I didn’t find interesting. I always feel a bit ‘guilty’ when I say I don’t like books that other people regard as modern classics, or books that everyone but myself seem to love, so it kind of hurts to give it just one star (with a reminder that to me, one star just means I didn’t like it, not necessarily an awful book) though that’s just me — maybe you’ll find it more interesting than I did (apparently lots of people do, haha).
My Rating: 1/5
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)












