This post originally published December 22, 2009.
Author: Melissa Marr
Published: 2009
Publisher: Harper Collins
Series: Wicked Lovely series #3
389 pages (hardcover)
Summary: Aislinn and Seth are still trying to adjust
to their relationship. After all, Aislinn is a faery who will live
forever, and Seth is a mortal with finite time. Not to mention Aislinn’s
king, Keenan, is still intent on winning over Aislinn’s heart, so that
their Court may become stronger. Seth decides he wants to be a faery as
well, despite everyone’s warning that that is a bad decision. The only
problem is that Seth doesn’t know how to go about changing his
mortality, until his best friend, the Dark King Niall unintentionally
informs him that the High Queen Sorcha has such power. In the meantime,
the War Faery Bananach is pulling some strings from the background,
attempting to create a massive war between all four Faery Courts.
My Thoughts: There is a novel between Wicked Lovely and this one in Marr’s faery series, called Ink Exchange,
but I didn’t read it. It’s more of a companion novel, as it deals with a
different set of characters. I understood the events in Fragile Eternity even without reading Ink Exchange first. The book mentions a few events that happened in Ink Exchange, but nothing you can’t figure out on your own as you read.
Anyway, despite Wicked Lovely leaving me kind of iffy about
the series, I decided to give the series another chance, and I’m glad I
did. While I can’t say I’m now a fan of the series, Fragile Eternity was a pleasant read. The plot was by far more interesting than Wicked Lovely,
I really like the direction the series is heading in. I think what
convinced me to continue with the series is the world if Faery. It’s
really intriguing, with the Four Faery Courts and the way they balance
with one another, it’s one of my favourite aspects of the series, and Fragile Eternity
does not disappoint with regards to that. It built on and expanded the
Faery world. It’s really a beautiful and haunting world that Marr has
created in the series.
I still feel issues with the characters, primarily the faery
characters (which is pretty much all the characters, hahaha). Everyone
is still pretty one-dimensional or two-dimensional at most; flat. Take
Bananach, the War Faery for example. She is the villain of Fragile Eternity and I was disappointed that this new villain was pretty much the same as Beira was in Wicked Lovely
— the same one-facet personality. Not a different facet either, the two
have essentially the same personality! Not to mention I simply can’t
understand Bananach. Granted, she’s supposed to be ‘insane’ but there’s
something random about how she appears out of nowhere giggling about
wanting to start some sort of war between all the Courts. Perhaps this
was explained in Ink Exchange? Other faeries, such as Keenan and Donia, remain the same as they were in Wicked Lovely,
nothing new about them. I was a little shocked at Seth’s drastic
personality change near the end of the book. Even given the
circumstances he was in, it was just such a big change.
At times, the book felt a bit repetitive. There is a constant repeat
that ‘if X happens, war might occur!’ or ‘Aislinn doesn’t really love
Keenan but he is her King’. They just get rephrased over and over again,
that after a while, as a reader, I wanted to say, “I know already!”
Overall? I liked this book. Fragile Eternity is what Wicked Lovely
should have been — intense, haunting and beautiful. If there are any
future books in this series, which I suspect there will be because of
the way Fragile Eternity ended, I will definitely pick them up to read.
My Rating: 3/5
Showing posts with label melissa marr. Show all posts
Showing posts with label melissa marr. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 30, 2015
Fragile Eternity
Labels:
fantasy,
melissa marr,
urban fantasy,
young adult
Wicked Lovely
Originally published December 8, 2009.
Author: Melissa Marr
Published: 2007
Publisher: HarperTeen
Series: Wicked Lovely series #1
328 pages (paperback)
Summary: Ever since she can remember, Aislinn has been told by her Gram that she must not look at, must not speak to and must not attract the attention of the faeries that walk the streets, invisible from mortals’ eyes, except her’s. They are described as both wicked and lovely, who like to play play tricks on mortals and will blind or kill humans that can see them. One day, however, she is approached by a faery named Keenan who tries to court her and Aislinn’s life is turned all upside down because of this: she can’t go to school normally, can’t go out normally, and regrets dragging her best friend Seth into the ordeal. She tries to avoid Keenan but he won’t stop following her. Keenan believes Aislinn might be the Summer Queen he had been waiting centuries for, the one who may be able to stop his evil mother, the Winter Queen, from freezing the world and killing all faeries and mortals alike.
My Thoughts: Faeries aren’t cute little winged creatures in this novel. Some are beautiful, while others are described as grotesque. It’s what attracted me to the novel in the first place. The beginning prologue-thing was eerie and dark, I enjoyed it. It’s a decent novel, but I had trouble staying interested. Virtually nothing happens in the entire first half of the novel — it is filled with a lot of Aislinn walking around, from home to Seth’s to school, rinse and repeat. Most of the dialogue is to build the relationship between Seth and Aislinn. Most of Aislinn’s thoughts revolve around wondering what the faeries want. Nothing actually happens, the first half just drags on and on as if it was just filling up space.
The story never explicitly states what the faeries want either so I was as confused as Aislinn was. It’s up to the reader to piece together the pieces, which wouldn’t be a problem at all if it weren’t for the fact that there appears to be missing pieces, or pieces handed to the reader too late. The faeries speak of a serious ‘game’ they are playing, but nobody explains what the game is, or gives enough hints to the reader to figure it out, not until about three quarters of the way in. Despite being confused, I patiently read through the first half to get to the second half. The second half was a little better, mainly dealing with Keenan trying to convince Aislinn to be his Queen, and things began to make a little more sense but at the end of the novel, I still had many unanswered questions.
I couldn’t relate or care about any of the characters. Everyone seems so emotionless. For the most part, all the characters are trying to keep calm and keep their cool. I think the only character I did care about was Seth, even though I had some issues with him too (I don’t care how long I’ve been friends with someone, if my best friend/boyfriend/someone I care about told me she or he had always been able to see faeries, I can’t see myself accepting that like “Oh, really? Cool so what do we do about that now?”)
But the book isn’t bad by any stretch of the imagination. The writing is excellent: when Marr describes winter’s chill, I actually felt chilly, and when she described the warm summer sun, I felt warm myself. I love the dark, slightly gothic feel to the novel. I love the concept of the ‘game’ the faeries play, and the rules that make it oh-so-intriguing. I wish it was explained more in-depth so I can better understand it and its purpose. The ending was great too, if not a bit predictable, and I am quite satisfied with how each character’s part in the story concludes (or at least, until Fragile Eternity, the sequel, which I can’t quite decide if I want to read at this point). It is overall a decent, average book despite its confusing-ness, just have to have the patience to sit through the first half.
My Rating: 2.5/5
Author: Melissa Marr
Published: 2007
Publisher: HarperTeen
Series: Wicked Lovely series #1
328 pages (paperback)
Summary: Ever since she can remember, Aislinn has been told by her Gram that she must not look at, must not speak to and must not attract the attention of the faeries that walk the streets, invisible from mortals’ eyes, except her’s. They are described as both wicked and lovely, who like to play play tricks on mortals and will blind or kill humans that can see them. One day, however, she is approached by a faery named Keenan who tries to court her and Aislinn’s life is turned all upside down because of this: she can’t go to school normally, can’t go out normally, and regrets dragging her best friend Seth into the ordeal. She tries to avoid Keenan but he won’t stop following her. Keenan believes Aislinn might be the Summer Queen he had been waiting centuries for, the one who may be able to stop his evil mother, the Winter Queen, from freezing the world and killing all faeries and mortals alike.
My Thoughts: Faeries aren’t cute little winged creatures in this novel. Some are beautiful, while others are described as grotesque. It’s what attracted me to the novel in the first place. The beginning prologue-thing was eerie and dark, I enjoyed it. It’s a decent novel, but I had trouble staying interested. Virtually nothing happens in the entire first half of the novel — it is filled with a lot of Aislinn walking around, from home to Seth’s to school, rinse and repeat. Most of the dialogue is to build the relationship between Seth and Aislinn. Most of Aislinn’s thoughts revolve around wondering what the faeries want. Nothing actually happens, the first half just drags on and on as if it was just filling up space.
The story never explicitly states what the faeries want either so I was as confused as Aislinn was. It’s up to the reader to piece together the pieces, which wouldn’t be a problem at all if it weren’t for the fact that there appears to be missing pieces, or pieces handed to the reader too late. The faeries speak of a serious ‘game’ they are playing, but nobody explains what the game is, or gives enough hints to the reader to figure it out, not until about three quarters of the way in. Despite being confused, I patiently read through the first half to get to the second half. The second half was a little better, mainly dealing with Keenan trying to convince Aislinn to be his Queen, and things began to make a little more sense but at the end of the novel, I still had many unanswered questions.
I couldn’t relate or care about any of the characters. Everyone seems so emotionless. For the most part, all the characters are trying to keep calm and keep their cool. I think the only character I did care about was Seth, even though I had some issues with him too (I don’t care how long I’ve been friends with someone, if my best friend/boyfriend/someone I care about told me she or he had always been able to see faeries, I can’t see myself accepting that like “Oh, really? Cool so what do we do about that now?”)
But the book isn’t bad by any stretch of the imagination. The writing is excellent: when Marr describes winter’s chill, I actually felt chilly, and when she described the warm summer sun, I felt warm myself. I love the dark, slightly gothic feel to the novel. I love the concept of the ‘game’ the faeries play, and the rules that make it oh-so-intriguing. I wish it was explained more in-depth so I can better understand it and its purpose. The ending was great too, if not a bit predictable, and I am quite satisfied with how each character’s part in the story concludes (or at least, until Fragile Eternity, the sequel, which I can’t quite decide if I want to read at this point). It is overall a decent, average book despite its confusing-ness, just have to have the patience to sit through the first half.
My Rating: 2.5/5
Labels:
fantasy,
melissa marr,
urban fantasy,
young adult
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

