Showing posts with label alison weir. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alison weir. Show all posts

Friday, October 2, 2015

The Lady Elizabeth

This post first published February 23, 2013.

Author: Alison Weir
First Published: April 2008
Publisher: Ballantine Books
512 pages (trade paperback)
 
The Lady Elizabeth is a novel about Elizabeth I’s life from toddlerhood to when she is declared the new Queen of England. It’s a pretty straightforward book, almost like a biography that is written narratively. The book is split into three sections: The King’s Daughter, The King’s Sister and The Queen’s Sister. Each section details her life when she was in each role. Throughout the novel, this novel tries to give perspective into why Elizabeth I became the famous Virgin Queen she is known to be today.

If you already know the general story of Elizabeth before she became Queen, then there are not going to be very many surprises in this book for you. When I first got this book, I actually was more interested in Queen Elizabeth’s reign and didn’t realize this book had nothing much to do with her actual reign. It has everything about Elizabeth up to the moment Queen Mary I dies. So, this wasn’t exactly what I was looking for and I suppose my opinion of this novel is a bit coloured by that. However, I guess it’s my own fault for thinking it was going to include her reign even though it did not really give any hints that it would.

Overall, I liked this book but it did not feel as thrilling or irresistible a read as Alison Weir’s other two books I’ve read. I am already kind of familiar with Elizabeth’s pre-queen life, a large chunk of which I read about in Alison Weir’s other historical novel, Innocent Traitor. The overlap of that time period that Jane (from Innocent Traitor) and Elizabeth shared felt like a rerun of an episode to me since the same author wrote both books. However, I think if you never read an Alison Weir book, or you never read anything about Elizabeth before, you will likely find this book a lot more exciting. I really like Alison Weir’s historical novels because she is a historian herself and she tries to stick to the facts, and only makes things up to fill in unknown gaps in history. I also particularly like that she tries to include as much of the actual known dialogues/quotes that characters have spoken.

There are some new fictional bits in this book you may not encounter in other books — mainly, they are plots to explain certain gaps in our present understanding of Elizabeth’s life. For example, the rumors about Elizabeth and Thomas Seymour. Nobody really knows what went on between them, historically. This book gives one possible guess (I mean, that’s the great thing about historical fiction: you can fill in the gaps of historical knowledge for fun with no repercussions).  I enjoy the speculation as well, and I like reading the little author’s note at the end of Weir’s books where she explains why she thought it could have happened this way or that way.

Overall, this was a solid novel. I think my very slight disappointment with it is due more to my own expectations and familiarity with the author’s perspective on Elizabeth than the quality of the novel itself. Like I said, if you don’t know anything about Elizabeth or you never read a Weir book before, I think you would enjoy it more.

My Rating: 3/5

Captive Queen

This post first published July 20, 2012.

Author: Alison Weir
First Published: March 2010
Published: Ballantine Books
473 pages (paperback)
 
This is my second Alison Weir book. I loved her first one, Innocent Traitor, on Lady Jane Grey and was very excited to read more of her works. Captive Queen is about Eleanor of Aquitaine, who, despite my limited knowledge on her, is a favourite Queen of mine from history. This book has its flaws, but I thought overall it was quite well done and I was pretty addicted to reading it. The book starts off a bit slow, but builds up increasingly. By the middle of the book, I couldn’t put it down at all.

Captive Queen begins when Eleanor is almost thirty years old, beginning with her failure of a marriage to King Louis of France. Eleanor is a beautiful, headstrong Queen with a high sex drive; unfortunately, her husband is so pious that Eleanor practically needs to beg him to come to bed with her, for the sake of an heir at least. When Eleanor lays her eyes on young Henry of Anjou (future King Henry of England), eleven years her junior, she is instantly attracted — and so is he. Daringly, Eleanor arranges for her marriage to Louis to become annulled and before anyone can say anything, she is wed to Henry. Their relationship is extremely passionate, as Henry shares the same sexual appetite as her and together, they eventually come to have eight children.

However, as the years go on, Eleanor and Henry’s relationship begins to break down. Though they can’t get enough of one another in the bedroom, outside they are butting heads politically over land and over their children. Finding out about Henry’s faithlessness also drives the wedge deeper between them. When Eleanor’s sons revolt against their father, Eleanor can’t help but side with her sons, a decision that will cost her her freedom.

As I mentioned earlier, the book begins a bit on the slow side. I still liked it, but it wasn’t anything too impressive. I read some reviews where people were unhappy with how much sex Eleanor and Henry had in the book, but that didn’t bother me one bit. I mean, they were both known to be quite into sex, it’s kind of hard to leave that out. However, I do agree that the beginning of the book seemed to be overly dominated with sex scenes and sexual-related scenes and the like. I guess it just drove home how much of Eleanor and Henry’s relationship was built upon pure, unrestrained lust — and unfortunately, lust doesn’t last.

What I loved was reading about Eleanor and Henry’s relationship dissolving. In some ways, this book isn’t really about just Eleanor, but rather, Eleanor and Henry. They couldn’t agree on so many things outside of the bedroom. Henry wanted things one way, Eleanor wanted things another way. Eleanor, who was quite an intelligent woman herself, resented the fact that Henry technically had control of her lands as her husband, even though none of her vassals liked Henry. She would try to persuade Henry to let her handle her own vassals since they like her more, but Henry is too prideful, too “manly” to let a woman handle his affairs. Then there was also Becket, Henry’s new BFF, who came between Eleanor and Henry’s relationship even more. She hated that she wasn’t the first person Henry would turn to for advice anymore. When their children grew older, she sided with her sons who felt their father was hogging all the power, which of course, drove Eleanor and Henry apart even more. As morbid as it sounds, I loved reading about their marriage and relationship falling apart. It was exciting! Dramatic!

I loved this book a lot! No, it’s not perfect — I do wish the author focused a bit more on Eleanor’s children, specifically her sons — but it’s a great book on its own. Whether you are knowledgeable about Eleanor’s life or not, I think many people will find this book quite exciting to read.

My Rating: 4.5/5


Thursday, October 1, 2015

Innocent Traitor

This post first published June 19, 2012.

Author: Alison Weir
First published: April 2006
Publisher: Ballantine Books
397 pages (paperback)
 
I actually have never, ever heard of Lady Jane Grey before reading this book. I remember, while hunting for some historical royal fiction at the bookstore, initially looking at the back cover, seeing her name amongst other names I am more familiar with like Henry VIII and Queen Mary, thinking, “Who the heck is Jane Grey? Why is there an entire book about her?” Curiosity, as well as many Goodreads reviews singing its praises, convinced me to try the book. After reading it, I don’t think I can ever forget Jane Grey, The Nine Days Queen.

Lady Jane Grey was born during the reign of King Henry VIII. Her parents, the Duke and Duchess of Suffolk, were very disappointed that she was not the son and male heir that they hoped for. Schemers and very ambitious, her parents decide that perhaps they can still use their daughter to their advantage, and hoped that the young heir of Henry, Prince Edward VI, will marry their daughter one day. After all, they do have Tudor blood in their veins. And so, Jane is brought up strictly and harshly by her parents, who try to mold her into a future Queen. Poor Jane endures years of physical and emotional abuse, with few moments of reprieve. At long last, an opportunity arises for Jane to take the throne and her parents greedily reach for it, despite Jane stating that she has no desire to become Queen.

Reading the book without knowing even the smallest bit about Jane Grey probably added to my enjoyment of the novel. I had no idea how things will turn out, for the most part (except for the very end, because her destiny was the prologue so you know already if she lives or dies at the end of the book). This book was written really well, and from the very first few pages, I was sucked into the story. I liked how there were no “useless” scenes — sometimes historical novels, for the sake of accuracy, like to put in scenes of things that really happened in time but have no real bearing on the actual plot of the novel. Thankfully, that never happened here. All the characters were wonderfully memorable as well, and are pretty much forever etched into my memory, especially Jane, despite myself not knowing any of these people before the book (okay, except Henry VIII …)

Weir paints Jane Grey as a very innocent girl, a complete pawn of her parents and others who wanted to maintain their power after Edward VI’s death. She shows Jane as a very intelligent girl, a devout Protestant and someone who can be outspoken if she wants to, but more often that not, is literally beaten into submission by her parents, husband and those around her. She was completely used, and really, my heart ached for her, not just for the character, but just knowing this stuff happened to a real person. It was so easy to sympathize for Jane, and oftentimes I felt angry on her behalf at all the injustices being handed to her. I remember thinking, “Geez, this girl just cannot catch a break, can she? Poor girl.” And then I would have to keep reading and turning the pages to find out if she does. It was difficult putting this book down.

I like to read about the real person after I finish a historical novel. Granted, I only use Wikipedia, and maybe a few scattered webpages, as my “source”, but for my purpose, it is enough. From what I can tell, Alison Weir, who is already an established author of several non-fiction books regarding historical royalty, with this being her first foray into the fiction world, has written Innocent Traitor to be rather accurate of the actual events. Jane is, by and large, really seen as a reluctant Queen, the most unwilling accomplice to the conspiracy that unfolded. So if you are curious as to how historically accurate this book is (I know, there are some historical novels that just create really big events out of nowhere, and when you know you’re reading history (albeit in a fictitious manner), it can be a little shocking), I can tell you it’s quite good. I feel like I learned a lot!

When I finished this book, the first thing I did was jump on Amazon.ca and order Weir’s other book, The Lady Elizabeth (I actually do already have her other other book, The Captive Queen).  I can already tell that I am going to be a loyal fan of her works. I really, really loved this book and would most certainly recommend this to everyone.

My Rating: 5/5