This post first published June 23, 2014.
Author: Ally Condie
First Published: November 2012
Publisher: Dutton
Series: Matched #3
512 pages (hardcover)
If you’ve read my reviews for the first two books
of this series, you might be wondering why I bothered reading book
three, Reached, at all, since I didn’t really like the first two books
that much. Well, my line of thinking was something like, “I’ve come this
far, it’s the last book.” I didn’t really care about how the story was
going to end, but I did want some sort of closure with the series. Well,
I got to the end and it’s pretty much the same as the first two books,
though somehow this one managed to be even more boring.
So, the Rising (the rebellion) is supposed to be up and fighting the
Society in this final book.During all this, there is a Plague going
around and our main characters are trying very hard to find the Cure
for. Even worse, the Plague mutates, so that their previous Cure no
longer works and they have to find a new one. And of course, during all
these events, it is expected (as the third and final book in the series
and all), that Cassia is going to finally make a proper decision between
Xander and Ky, the two boys who are in love with her.
It all sounds very exciting, but it wasn’t. I thought book two was
going to be the most boring book in the series, but I was wrong: book
three is! The first 300-ish pages of this book, it honestly felt like
nothing was happening. There is nothing that happens that sticks out in
my mind. There was just so much “fluff” writing. It felt like the author
wanted to be “deep” and thoughtful in her writing, but none of it was
convincing. And while I normally like poetry, I don’t buy what this book
(or rather, this series) has done with poems. They become almost like a
form of currency, people trading bits of poems to get what they want.
Why would a bunch of rebels who can’t even write decide that poetry was
worth anything? I hardly think their Society mandated education would
help them learn how to appreciate poetry, especially poetry that was
written decades or even centuries ago. Maybe modern poetry … Anyway, I
digress …
I kept expecting the Rising to finally do something against the
Society. But there was no fighting, no nothing! I don’t NEED there to be
actual fighting to be interesting, but I did expect something exciting
to go down. Instead, I got this super anti-climatic realization from
Cassia that the Rising and the Society are one, that the Society
engineered the Rising to make people think there’s change and be
satisfied. The reveal was not very exciting and the events that followed
this realization were pretty boring!
The love story between Cassia, Xander and Ky ended very predictably
too. I did not expect the “leftover” boy to find love too, but he did.
That didn’t make me feel happy though. I feel that having the “leftover”
boy find true love suddenly just undermines the “leftover” boy’s
feelings for Cassia during the entire series. If he can love another
girl so soon after Cassia makes up her mind about who she wants to be
with, then he never truly loved Cassia at all, you know?
I don’t feel satisfied after reading this final book, but I can’t
really say I’m disappointed either. I just feel nothing, like none of it
mattered.
My Rating: 2/5
Showing posts with label ally condie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ally condie. Show all posts
Friday, October 2, 2015
Reached
Labels:
2,
ally condie,
dystopia,
science fiction,
young adult
Crossed
This post first published August 24, 2012.
Author: Ally Condie
Series: Matched #2
First Published: November 2011
Publisher: Dutton Juvenile
367 pages (hardcover)
The first book, Matched, didn’t really impress me that much but I kind of wanted to find out what happens anyway, so I got this second book from the library. Unfortunately, I liked Crossed even less than I like Matched. In a nutshell, Crossed was boring. At least in the first book, stuff happened. Nothing much happens in this book. You could probably skip this book and jump into the third one with little problem.
In Crossed, the story is narrated by both Cassia and Ky in alternating chapters, unlike the first book. Ky has been sent to the Outer Provinces for “work”, but really, has been sentenced to die. Cassia, desperate to reunite with Ky, goes with her work group to the Outer Provinces as well, and when the perfect opportunity arises, runs away with the help of a new friend, Indie. Together, they try to find Ky, who has also escaped from his “work”. Together, their little group try to piece together fragments of clues that hint that there is a rebellion group, the Rising, which Cassia and Indie want to find and join. Ky, on the other hand, has reservations about joining the Rising. Or, in short, there is a rebellion called the Rising, which Cassia and Ky end up joining. Boom, that’s the whole book.
The entire plot of this book could have been condensed and packed into whatever the next book contains, or the previous book. To me, this book’s plot is simple and short, but the author stretched it to fill one book’s worth. The result was a book that moved at a snail’s pace and felt like nothing much was happening most of the time. At the end of the book, I felt like the characters and the story have not progressed very far from where they were when Matched ended. Even Cassia and Ky’s relationship felt stagnant, and in this book, a bit overdone. I can tell the author was trying to make their relationship more deep and meaningful, but it did not work, at least for me. Cassia and Ky’s relationship always felt a bit forced to me, but it’s like full force in this book. Over and over again, the two of them monologue’d about how much they love one another, how they would do anything for one another, writing/thinking poetry about one another (literally). I felt like they were trying to convince me that they were deeply in love, but it came off as too forced instead.
Also combined with the thin plot was the author’s writing style. I think the author writes really well and beautifully. I have no qualms with Ally Condie’s writing. The problem is she writes almost too well. The boring story combined with the poetic, dramatic writing style of the author meant reading a lot about overly wordy passages, another reason why I think this book feels like it was really forced.
Lastly, the setting of this book was quite stagnant and never changed very much. We are no longer in Society where there’s all sorts of different places the characters could visit. We are with Cassia, Ky and their friends running around a canyon for the entire book. There are only rocks, caves and rivers which were repeatedly described.
All in all, I was not impressed with Crossed. I know I wasn’t that crazy about Matched either, but I did think it had potential to get better, so Crossed was rather disappointing. Am I going to read book three? Well, I’ve come this far and it’s the last book, so I’ll probably read it for the closure.
My Rating: 2/5
Author: Ally Condie
Series: Matched #2
First Published: November 2011
Publisher: Dutton Juvenile
367 pages (hardcover)
The first book, Matched, didn’t really impress me that much but I kind of wanted to find out what happens anyway, so I got this second book from the library. Unfortunately, I liked Crossed even less than I like Matched. In a nutshell, Crossed was boring. At least in the first book, stuff happened. Nothing much happens in this book. You could probably skip this book and jump into the third one with little problem.
In Crossed, the story is narrated by both Cassia and Ky in alternating chapters, unlike the first book. Ky has been sent to the Outer Provinces for “work”, but really, has been sentenced to die. Cassia, desperate to reunite with Ky, goes with her work group to the Outer Provinces as well, and when the perfect opportunity arises, runs away with the help of a new friend, Indie. Together, they try to find Ky, who has also escaped from his “work”. Together, their little group try to piece together fragments of clues that hint that there is a rebellion group, the Rising, which Cassia and Indie want to find and join. Ky, on the other hand, has reservations about joining the Rising. Or, in short, there is a rebellion called the Rising, which Cassia and Ky end up joining. Boom, that’s the whole book.
The entire plot of this book could have been condensed and packed into whatever the next book contains, or the previous book. To me, this book’s plot is simple and short, but the author stretched it to fill one book’s worth. The result was a book that moved at a snail’s pace and felt like nothing much was happening most of the time. At the end of the book, I felt like the characters and the story have not progressed very far from where they were when Matched ended. Even Cassia and Ky’s relationship felt stagnant, and in this book, a bit overdone. I can tell the author was trying to make their relationship more deep and meaningful, but it did not work, at least for me. Cassia and Ky’s relationship always felt a bit forced to me, but it’s like full force in this book. Over and over again, the two of them monologue’d about how much they love one another, how they would do anything for one another, writing/thinking poetry about one another (literally). I felt like they were trying to convince me that they were deeply in love, but it came off as too forced instead.
Also combined with the thin plot was the author’s writing style. I think the author writes really well and beautifully. I have no qualms with Ally Condie’s writing. The problem is she writes almost too well. The boring story combined with the poetic, dramatic writing style of the author meant reading a lot about overly wordy passages, another reason why I think this book feels like it was really forced.
Lastly, the setting of this book was quite stagnant and never changed very much. We are no longer in Society where there’s all sorts of different places the characters could visit. We are with Cassia, Ky and their friends running around a canyon for the entire book. There are only rocks, caves and rivers which were repeatedly described.
All in all, I was not impressed with Crossed. I know I wasn’t that crazy about Matched either, but I did think it had potential to get better, so Crossed was rather disappointing. Am I going to read book three? Well, I’ve come this far and it’s the last book, so I’ll probably read it for the closure.
My Rating: 2/5
Labels:
2,
ally condie,
dystopia,
science fiction,
young adult
Matched
This post first published August 22, 2012.
Author: Ally Condie
Series: Matched #1
First Published: November 2010
Publisher: Penguin Group
238 pages (eBook)
I was initially attracted to this book because I heard it was a dystopia, and also the covers (for this one and its sequels) are so interesting and lovely. I’m a little disappointed in the book, but I am still somewhat curious as to how it’s all going to go down in the end, so I think I’ll continue onto book two.
Matched takes place in a world where everything is strictly controlled and regulated by the government. They pick where you work, they pick who you marry, they pick your food for you, they pick your clothes for you, everything. Our main character is Cassia, a cheerful 17 year old girl about to become Matched. The government runs all the 17 year olds’ data and match them to their perfect partner, and they are very good at this. Essentially, the government knows who your soul mate is. Cassia is very lucky and gets Matched to her childhood best friend, Xander.
Cassia has never questioned the way Society is before, but when the microchip containing her Match’s information glitches and she sees the photo of another boy on her screen, she wonders how her perfect Society could have made a mistake. Even stranger, she recognizes the glitched boy as a boy in her neighbourhood named Ky. All this gets Cassia to start questioning her Society and wondering if it was possible that she and Ky are the real Match and not her and Xander.
I was super interested in the idea that the government picks who you marry, which is the premise of this novel. I liked the way this book began and it really sucked me in at first. However, shortly after, the book went in a direction that I wasn’t too crazy about. The whole being matched thing kind of faded to the background. It was really just a springboard to help Cassia start questioning her supposedly perfect society. She realizes that everyone is so controlled, no one gets to have a say about anything. No one can make any of their own choices. Then she gets closer to Ky, and she realizes she wants to be able to choose between Xander and Ky. All that wasn’t bad, it’s just that it was presented in a rather dull way. I admit, I kind of got bored reading this book.
I don’t think this was a particularly well built story world, although it does have loads of potential. I heard it was very similar to The Giver by Lois Lowry, although I haven’t read that book so I can’t say much about it. Anyway, some parts of it feel perfectly dystopian-ish and then some parts were just bizarre or confusing. For example, how is it possible that everyone knows how to type, but nobody knows how to write the actual alphabet? It’s the same symbols, I can’t imagine it being that far of a leap to copy something from the screen to paper. I mean, if I knew how to read Russian on my computer, for example, I’m sure some of the letters would have stuck in my mind. Also, Ky is labeled as an Aberration, which supposedly makes him an imperfect match for Cassia, but what is an Aberration exactly? It is not explained in the book. All I know is that aberration means ‘something that deviates from the norm’, and that doesn’t tell me a whole lot about Ky.
The love triangle relationship between Cassia and the two boys was a bit lackluster as well, although at the very end, I did really like the idea of Cassia and Ky being together and I was really sad when they got separated. I don’t know when it happened, but I really started to root for them and their separation scene was a little touching (though bordering on cheesiness a bit, heh). Anyway, I understand Cassia and Xander’s relationship. They are a very standard boy-meets-girl next door kind of couple who are both absolutely perfect and good. I am not quite sure how Cassia started to fall in love with Ky so hard (although, like I said, I like them together regardless). Cassia doesn’t even really know Ky until his face popped up on her glitched microchip, then suddenly she’s super interested in him and falls madly in love with him. Which is doubly weird because Ky is a strong and silent kind of guy, broods a lot, so I don’t know what he did to become attractive in her eyes if she never even noticed him in the first place, and he’s lived on the same street as her for years. I suppose it just drives to home the idea that Society knows who your perfect soulmates are.
In the end, I thought this book was okay. It didn’t amaze me, but it didn’t feel like a chore to finish either. It’s also a rather short book (well, short compared to what I usually read), so it didn’t take me ages to finish or something; I was just interested enough to read it all in one day, four hours. As I said at the beginning of this post, I am interested to see how the story will continue so I think I will give the second book a shot. I do hope the second book and I click better!
My Rating: 2/5
Author: Ally Condie
Series: Matched #1
First Published: November 2010
Publisher: Penguin Group
238 pages (eBook)
I was initially attracted to this book because I heard it was a dystopia, and also the covers (for this one and its sequels) are so interesting and lovely. I’m a little disappointed in the book, but I am still somewhat curious as to how it’s all going to go down in the end, so I think I’ll continue onto book two.
Matched takes place in a world where everything is strictly controlled and regulated by the government. They pick where you work, they pick who you marry, they pick your food for you, they pick your clothes for you, everything. Our main character is Cassia, a cheerful 17 year old girl about to become Matched. The government runs all the 17 year olds’ data and match them to their perfect partner, and they are very good at this. Essentially, the government knows who your soul mate is. Cassia is very lucky and gets Matched to her childhood best friend, Xander.
Cassia has never questioned the way Society is before, but when the microchip containing her Match’s information glitches and she sees the photo of another boy on her screen, she wonders how her perfect Society could have made a mistake. Even stranger, she recognizes the glitched boy as a boy in her neighbourhood named Ky. All this gets Cassia to start questioning her Society and wondering if it was possible that she and Ky are the real Match and not her and Xander.
I was super interested in the idea that the government picks who you marry, which is the premise of this novel. I liked the way this book began and it really sucked me in at first. However, shortly after, the book went in a direction that I wasn’t too crazy about. The whole being matched thing kind of faded to the background. It was really just a springboard to help Cassia start questioning her supposedly perfect society. She realizes that everyone is so controlled, no one gets to have a say about anything. No one can make any of their own choices. Then she gets closer to Ky, and she realizes she wants to be able to choose between Xander and Ky. All that wasn’t bad, it’s just that it was presented in a rather dull way. I admit, I kind of got bored reading this book.
I don’t think this was a particularly well built story world, although it does have loads of potential. I heard it was very similar to The Giver by Lois Lowry, although I haven’t read that book so I can’t say much about it. Anyway, some parts of it feel perfectly dystopian-ish and then some parts were just bizarre or confusing. For example, how is it possible that everyone knows how to type, but nobody knows how to write the actual alphabet? It’s the same symbols, I can’t imagine it being that far of a leap to copy something from the screen to paper. I mean, if I knew how to read Russian on my computer, for example, I’m sure some of the letters would have stuck in my mind. Also, Ky is labeled as an Aberration, which supposedly makes him an imperfect match for Cassia, but what is an Aberration exactly? It is not explained in the book. All I know is that aberration means ‘something that deviates from the norm’, and that doesn’t tell me a whole lot about Ky.
The love triangle relationship between Cassia and the two boys was a bit lackluster as well, although at the very end, I did really like the idea of Cassia and Ky being together and I was really sad when they got separated. I don’t know when it happened, but I really started to root for them and their separation scene was a little touching (though bordering on cheesiness a bit, heh). Anyway, I understand Cassia and Xander’s relationship. They are a very standard boy-meets-girl next door kind of couple who are both absolutely perfect and good. I am not quite sure how Cassia started to fall in love with Ky so hard (although, like I said, I like them together regardless). Cassia doesn’t even really know Ky until his face popped up on her glitched microchip, then suddenly she’s super interested in him and falls madly in love with him. Which is doubly weird because Ky is a strong and silent kind of guy, broods a lot, so I don’t know what he did to become attractive in her eyes if she never even noticed him in the first place, and he’s lived on the same street as her for years. I suppose it just drives to home the idea that Society knows who your perfect soulmates are.
In the end, I thought this book was okay. It didn’t amaze me, but it didn’t feel like a chore to finish either. It’s also a rather short book (well, short compared to what I usually read), so it didn’t take me ages to finish or something; I was just interested enough to read it all in one day, four hours. As I said at the beginning of this post, I am interested to see how the story will continue so I think I will give the second book a shot. I do hope the second book and I click better!
My Rating: 2/5
Labels:
2,
ally condie,
dystopia,
science fiction,
young adult
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


