Showing posts with label dystopia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dystopia. Show all posts

Friday, October 2, 2015

Mockingjay

This post first published May 15, 2011.

Author: Suzanne Collins
Published: August 2010
Publisher: Scholastic Press
Series: The Hunger Games #3
390 pages (hardcover)
 
As the final book of the series, I don’t think Mockingjay does The Hunger Games justice. I think this book bombed. If you are planning to read this series, I’d suggest stopping after book two, but with that cliffhanger, I suppose you’d feel compelled to read book three anyway. I wanted to like this book, I tried to like this book, but I found it hard to pretend. And I’m going to apologize ahead of time that half of this post contains spoilers (which are marked).

In Catching Fire, we were left off with the most aggravating-in-a-good-way cliffhanger: “There is no District 12.” In this book, we find out District 12 has been destroyed by the Capitol after Katniss escaped from the Hunger Games arena, and less than 10% of District 12’s population has fled to the once thought to be non-existing District 13, who takes them in. Katniss and Peeta somehow get flung into opposite ends of the war: Katniss is wanted by the rebels to become their Mockingjay — the face of the rebellion, their symbol of hope. Peeta has been captured by the Capitol and is being used as the spokesperson for their own cause — a call for a ceasefire.

I’ll try not to be a negative Nancy by talking about the few things I did like first. Though I didn’t really have any characters I particularly liked or cared about in the first two books, I did in this one: Finnick! A secondary character, I know, but his background story is expanded in this novel and … I don’t know. I think I liked him because he’s the only one who doesn’t seem so bland. I also liked the concept of President Snow’s character. The whole blood and roses thing was pretty awesome, and really gave me an idea of what kind of villain we are dealing with. Seriously, two thumbs up for a great villain concept.

I can’t really think of anything more I liked … As for what I didn’t like … Well, I will start off with the general plot of the story. I didn’t find it engaging or interesting because so many of the things that should be engaging and interesting happen off camera or were seriously downplayed. (Contains Spoilers!) Example 1 – When Gale & Co. go rescue Peeta from the Capitol, Katniss just stays behind in District 13. Next page, bam! Hey Peeta’s back! I don’t know about you, but getting Peeta back seems important enough to me to happen on stage. Example 2 – Finnick’s death was brushed off like it was nothing. I know, he’s a secondary character, but surely his relationship with Katniss warranted more than just a, “Oh no! Finnick died! … Moving on now …” Example 3 – Pretty much the entire ending of the war happened off-screen. President Snow’s capture? Off screen. Katniss’ trial after she killed Coin? Off screen. I felt seriously robbed. These feel like HUGE moments, but instead all I got was Katniss locked up somewhere, and a few pages of reading about Katniss contemplating suicide later, a messenger arrives with, “Oh hey, uh, we decided you’re free in a trial that you didn’t even have to attend.” I mean, really?

Oh, and I must mention how I feel the message of the series got totally destroyed by the ending. This is what I thought the take-home message was: killing destroys people, it ruins them. It doesn’t fix anything, and you can’t rule through fear. Yet at the end, when Coin proposes a final Hunger Games for the children of Capitol citizens, Katniss agrees. Seriously?! I felt like that went against everything the books were telling me … evidently, I’ve been misinterpreting the entire series the entire time. It’s all good as long as it’s for justice?

Lastly, the love triangle thing was NOT resolved, in my opinion. Katniss ends up with Peeta … because Gale gets a job working in District 2 and doesn’t see her anymore. Really? Katniss ends up with Peeta because he’s the one who is physically closest to her? And Gale doesn’t even attempt to do anything about reaching out to Katniss, he just gives up? So much for being sooo in love with her. This all happens in one sentence: “Peeta and I grow back together.” Small paragraph explaining why Peeta and not Gale. The end. The love triangle thing has never felt like it fit in this series, but I mean, since it’s in the story now, I expected a better resolution. (End Spoilers)

My final thoughts are that Mockingjay is a letdown, and a disappointing end to a good series. For a book about life and death, friendship, trust and vengeance, it was utterly void of emotions due to the monotonous voice Collins employs to write her novels, and lack of inclusion of what I believe to be key scenes. I feel that Collins had a strong idea for The Hunger Games, but no strong direction as to what should occur in the series’ subsequent novels, and it really shows in Mockingjay. This was a frustrating read for me, I’m sad to say.

I considered giving just one star, but you know what? I still think overall, the series is good, and Mockingjay had its small, rare moments.

My Rating: 1.5/5

Reached

This post first published June 23, 2014.

Author: Ally Condie
First Published: November 2012
Publisher: Dutton
Series: Matched #3
512 pages (hardcover)
 
If you’ve read my reviews for the first two books of this series, you might be wondering why I bothered reading book three, Reached, at all, since I didn’t really like the first two books that much. Well, my line of thinking was something like, “I’ve come this far, it’s the last book.” I didn’t really care about how the story was going to end, but I did want some sort of closure with the series. Well, I got to the end and it’s pretty much the same as the first two books, though somehow this one managed to be even more boring.

So, the Rising (the rebellion) is supposed to be up and fighting the Society in this final book.During all this, there is a Plague going around and our main characters are trying very hard to find the Cure for. Even worse, the Plague mutates, so that their previous Cure no longer works and they have to find a new one. And of course, during all these events, it is expected (as the third and final book in the series and all), that Cassia is going to finally make a proper decision between Xander and Ky, the two boys who are in love with her.

It all sounds very exciting, but it wasn’t. I thought book two was going to be the most boring book in the series, but I was wrong: book three is! The first 300-ish pages of this book, it honestly felt like nothing was happening. There is nothing that happens that sticks out in my mind. There was just so much “fluff” writing. It felt like the author wanted to be “deep” and thoughtful in her writing, but none of it was convincing. And while I normally like poetry, I don’t buy what this book (or rather, this series) has done with poems. They become almost like a form of currency, people trading bits of poems to get what they want. Why would a bunch of rebels who can’t even write decide that poetry was worth anything? I hardly think their Society mandated education would help them learn how to appreciate poetry, especially poetry that was written decades or even centuries ago. Maybe modern poetry … Anyway, I digress …

I kept expecting the Rising to finally do something against the Society. But there was no fighting, no nothing! I don’t NEED there to be actual fighting to be interesting, but I did expect something exciting to go down. Instead, I got this super anti-climatic realization from Cassia that the Rising and the Society are one, that the Society engineered the Rising to make people think there’s change and be satisfied. The reveal was not very exciting and the events that followed this realization were pretty boring!

The love story between Cassia, Xander and Ky ended very predictably too. I did not expect the “leftover” boy to find love too, but he did. That didn’t make me feel happy though. I feel that having the “leftover” boy find true love suddenly just undermines the “leftover” boy’s feelings for Cassia during the entire series. If he can love another girl so soon after Cassia makes up her mind about who she wants to be with, then he never truly loved Cassia at all, you know?

I don’t feel satisfied after reading this final book, but I can’t really say I’m disappointed either. I just feel nothing, like none of it mattered.

My Rating: 2/5

Oryx and Crake

This post first published March 19, 2013.

Author: Margaret Atwood
First Published: May 2003
Publisher: Vintage Canada
Series: MaddAdam #1
416 pages (mass market paperback)
 
Simply amazing!

Two years ago, I read The Year of the Flood by Margaret Atwood and thought it was a great book, even though the ending half threw me off a bit. Later, I realized the ending half of The Year of the Flood was actually the point of the story that picked up from the ending of another book, Oryx & Crake. That’s when I realized that I actually read the second book in a series!  No wonder I was a bit lost near the end. Anyway, I did like The Year of the Flood quite a bit regardless and told myself I’ll read Oryx & Crake ASAP so that everything makes sense. ASAP apparently means two years later to me, haha.

So yes, here I am, having finally finished the first book of this wonderful series. Oryx & Crake is told by Jimmy, or Snowman, as he likes to be called in the post-apocalyptic world. After a disastrous biological virus of some sort wipes out humanity, Snowman believes he is the last human alive. Everyday he struggles to survive in a world where the animals have been genetically modified to either be more docile than they usually are, or more vicious. He has considered just killing himself off and being done with everything, but he continues to live because he promised his close friends, Crake and Oryx, that he will watch over the Crakers.

The Crakers are genetically modified “humans” that are vastly different from Snowman. They were created by his genius friend Crake, back when the world was still whole. The story alternates between the present, and flashbacks of the past, when Snowman was Jimmy. Jimmy and Crake were best of friends, but Crake was always the more genius of the two. Even when they separated and went to different schools, they remained in touch. One day, Crake invites Jimmy to work at his company, and it is there that Jimmy begins to fully comprehend the genetic projects Crake has been up to. He is assisted by Oryx, a girl that Jimmy and Crake have actually seen in kiddie porn. Both boys fall in love with Oryx.

Like with The Year of the Flood, this is a book with a powerful vision of the future, one that is depressingly bleak. I really love this book, and enjoyed it even more than I did with The Year of the Flood. Unlike its sequel, Oryx & Crake wasn’t just all about the apocalyptic present; there was also the time when the world was seemingly perfect. To them, it was a utopic point of civilization; to the reader, it appears utterly dystopic. The world is ruled by corporations and companies, which really, if you keep up with the news, appears to be the eerily similar path we are heading down. People want to be healthier, fitter, smarter, more beautiful, for as little world as possible, and the corporations in this novel fully take advantage of that. It might sound crazy, but I love books like this that speculate on the future, no matter how awful it may be. I love picking out what is plausible and what isn’t. A lot of things in this book sound like it could possibly happen in the far future.

I liked this novel because there is almost a philosophical component to it, as well. For example, the Crakers bring up an interesting idea. Crake takes the idea of humans becoming better extreme when he creates the Crakers — why not just completely reinvent the human species? Crake gets rid of a lot of what he calls unnecessary human behaviours and creates a “human” that I would argue is not a human anymore, even if they physically resemble one. This book is also full of ideas for conspiracy theories — some people may already believe them! As an example, in the book, Crake says that humans have already pretty much invented the cure for everything, but they keep coming up with new viruses in order to sell more medicine. It is creepily possible … Incidentally, this is what leads to the entire human population dying, when a super virus goes haywire.

And, of course, the writing is fabulous. It was actually quite easy to read and I was hooked onto the story not too many chapters in. I had a hard time putting it down. I loved the characters, they were so memorable. I haven’t fully figured out what was going on between the three characters, specifically Crake and Oryx. They are both such mysterious characters. Crake, especially. You can never fully figure out what’s going on in Crake’s head, which I think is the point. When it comes to Crake, there are so many ways to speculate about why he is behaving the way he is.

I definitely recommend this book to everyone!

My Rating: 5/5

Crossed

This post first published August 24, 2012.

Author: Ally Condie
Series: Matched #2
First Published: November 2011
Publisher: Dutton Juvenile
367 pages (hardcover)
 
The first book, Matched, didn’t really impress me that much but I kind of wanted to find out what happens anyway, so I got this second book from the library. Unfortunately, I liked Crossed even less than I like Matched. In a nutshell, Crossed was boring. At least in the first book, stuff happened. Nothing much happens in this book. You could probably skip this book and jump into the third one with little problem.

In Crossed, the story is narrated by both Cassia and Ky in alternating chapters, unlike the first book. Ky has been sent to the Outer Provinces for “work”, but really, has been sentenced to die. Cassia, desperate to reunite with Ky, goes with her work group to the Outer Provinces as well, and when the perfect opportunity arises, runs away with the help of a new friend, Indie. Together, they try to find Ky, who has also escaped from his “work”. Together, their little group try to piece together fragments of clues that hint that there is a rebellion group, the Rising, which Cassia and Indie want to find and join. Ky, on the other hand, has reservations about joining the Rising. Or, in short, there is a rebellion called the Rising, which Cassia and Ky end up joining. Boom, that’s the whole book.

The entire plot of this book could have been condensed and packed into whatever the next book contains, or the previous book. To me, this book’s plot is simple and short, but the author stretched it to fill one book’s worth. The result was a book that moved at a snail’s pace and felt like nothing much was happening most of the time. At the end of the book, I felt like the characters and the story have not progressed very far from where they were when Matched ended. Even Cassia and Ky’s relationship felt stagnant, and in this book, a bit overdone. I can tell the author was trying to make their relationship more deep and meaningful, but it did not work, at least for me. Cassia and Ky’s relationship always felt a bit forced to me, but it’s like full force in this book. Over and over again, the two of them monologue’d about how much they love one another, how they would do anything for one another, writing/thinking poetry about one another (literally). I felt like they were trying to convince me that they were deeply in love, but it came off as too forced instead.

Also combined with the thin plot was the author’s writing style. I think the author writes really well and beautifully. I have no qualms with Ally Condie’s writing. The problem is she writes almost too well. The boring story combined with the poetic, dramatic writing style of the author meant reading a lot about overly wordy passages, another reason why I think this book feels like it was really forced.
Lastly, the setting of this book was quite stagnant and never changed very much. We are no longer in Society where there’s all sorts of different places the characters could visit. We are with Cassia, Ky and their friends running around a canyon for the entire book. There are only rocks, caves and rivers which were repeatedly described.

All in all, I was not impressed with Crossed. I know I wasn’t that crazy about Matched either, but I did think it had potential to get better, so Crossed was rather disappointing. Am I going to read book three? Well, I’ve come this far and it’s the last book, so I’ll probably read it for the closure.

My Rating: 2/5

Matched

This post first published August 22, 2012.

Author: Ally Condie
Series: Matched #1
First Published: November 2010
Publisher: Penguin Group
238 pages (eBook)
 
I was initially attracted to this book because I heard it was a dystopia, and also the covers (for this one and its sequels) are so interesting and lovely. I’m a little disappointed in the book, but I am still somewhat curious as to how it’s all going to go down in the end, so I think I’ll continue onto book two.

Matched takes place in a world where everything is strictly controlled and regulated by the government. They pick where you work, they pick who you marry, they pick your food for you, they pick your clothes for you, everything. Our main character is Cassia, a cheerful 17 year old girl about to become Matched. The government runs all the 17 year olds’ data and match them to their perfect partner, and they are very good at this. Essentially, the government knows who your soul mate is. Cassia is very lucky and gets Matched to her childhood best friend, Xander.

Cassia has never questioned the way Society is before, but when the microchip containing her Match’s information glitches and she sees the photo of another boy on her screen, she wonders how her perfect Society could have made a mistake. Even stranger, she recognizes the glitched boy as a boy in her neighbourhood named Ky. All this gets Cassia to start questioning her Society and wondering if it was possible that she and Ky are the real Match and not her and Xander.

I was super interested in the idea that the government picks who you marry, which is the premise of this novel. I liked the way this book began and it really sucked me in at first. However, shortly after, the book went in a direction that I wasn’t too crazy about. The whole being matched thing kind of faded to the background. It was really just a springboard to help Cassia start questioning her supposedly perfect society. She realizes that everyone is so controlled, no one gets to have a say about anything. No one can make any of their own choices. Then she gets closer to Ky, and she realizes she wants to be able to choose between Xander and Ky. All that wasn’t bad, it’s just that it was presented in a rather dull way. I admit, I kind of got bored reading this book.

I don’t think this was a particularly well built story world, although it does have loads of potential. I heard it was very similar to The Giver by Lois Lowry, although I haven’t read that book so I can’t say much about it. Anyway, some parts of it feel perfectly dystopian-ish and then some parts were just bizarre or confusing. For example, how is it possible that everyone knows how to type, but nobody knows how to write the actual alphabet? It’s the same symbols, I can’t imagine it being that far of a leap to copy something from the screen to paper. I mean, if I knew how to read Russian on my computer, for example, I’m sure some of the letters would have stuck in my mind. Also, Ky is labeled as an Aberration, which supposedly makes him an imperfect match for Cassia, but what is an Aberration exactly? It is not explained in the book. All I know is that aberration means ‘something that deviates from the norm’, and that doesn’t tell me a whole lot about Ky.

The love triangle relationship between Cassia and the two boys was a bit lackluster as well, although at the very end, I did really like the idea of Cassia and Ky being together and I was really sad when they got separated. I don’t know when it happened, but I really started to root for them and their separation scene was a little touching (though bordering on cheesiness a bit, heh). Anyway, I understand Cassia and Xander’s relationship. They are a very standard boy-meets-girl next door kind of couple who are both absolutely perfect and good. I am not quite sure how Cassia started to fall in love with Ky so hard (although, like I said, I like them together regardless). Cassia doesn’t even really know Ky until his face popped up on her glitched microchip, then suddenly she’s super interested in him and falls madly in love with him. Which is doubly weird because Ky is a strong and silent kind of guy, broods a lot, so I don’t know what he did to become attractive in her eyes if she never even noticed him in the first place, and he’s lived on the same street as her for years. I suppose it just drives to home the idea that Society knows who your perfect soulmates are.

In the end, I thought this book was okay. It didn’t amaze me, but it didn’t feel like a chore to finish either. It’s also a rather short book (well, short compared to what I usually read), so it didn’t take me ages to finish or something; I was just interested enough to read it all in one day, four hours. As I said at the beginning of this post, I am interested to see how the story will continue so I think I will give the second book a shot. I do hope the second book and I click better!

My Rating: 2/5

Thursday, October 1, 2015

Legend

This post first published June 26, 2012.


Author: Marie Lu
First Published: November 2011
Publisher: Putnam Juvenile
Series: Legend #1
305 pages (hardcover)
 
I had a hard time deciding if I felt this book was a 3 or a 4 to me. Ultimately, I settled for a 3.5, though Goodreads doesn’t do half points. Overall, I like this book, it was very action packed and it had a solid plot with likable characters. On the other hand, it didn’t feel like a stand-out, unique piece of fiction, mainly because I found it quite predictable, lacked a wow-factor, and blends in well with all the other futuristic YA novels available currently. The lack of good world building really bothered me as well.

Legend takes place in the far future where the United States of America has split into different factions — the Republic (Western US), the Colonies and the Patriots — and are warring against one another. The story alternates between the two main characters. Day is a 15 years old, lives in the slums of the Lake sector (previously L.A., I believe?) and is the Republic’s most wanted criminal. June is also 15, but unlike Day, she is from a wealthy family and is a military prodigy. When June’s older brother, Metias, is killed by Day, June sets out to hunt him down and bring him to justice. It becomes rather difficult when the two unknowingly form a friendship, and discover secrets of the Republic that put both their lives in danger.

The story, the characters and the writing were really well done, I think. It read a bit like a movie script, like watching a film, but I don’t really have any problems with that. It was definitely a very action-packed story, even if some parts of it bordered on the unbelievable side (15 year old soldiers in the USA? Even if it’s a broken USA, I don’t think the country would go backwards and start using child soldiers. Or maybe that’s the point, to show how backwards it has all become? I don’t know, I need more explanation on the history of this world, which I will elaborate on later). The story was exciting, though hardly unique. Many parts of it, like lovers who can’t be together because they live in “opposite worlds”, have been done to death in stories.  So it’s not unique, but I still think it was well done and the author does a really good job presenting it.

The book’s biggest downside is the world-building. Really, I would have rated this book as a 4 or even a 5 if world building actually existed in this book. It is never explained why the USA became separated into these different, individual nations and what exactly they are fighting about. Actually, I have no idea what they were fighting about. I also had no idea why Day was rebelling against the Republic. I mean, I know he was wronged by them once, but so have a million other boys before him, so I don’t know how or why he became this super notorious criminal; what does he get from that? Based on what happened to him, wouldn’t he rather lay low?

But by far, the most annoying thing was not knowing the history of the world. I couldn’t feel properly immersed into the world. At one point, Day reveals he has an old quarter from 1990 where it says the United states of America, making a big deal about how once America was united but no one knows. So obviously the history of the country is unknown to its own citizens. Why?! And how did it happen?! I don’t know, I feel this is a pretty important point to make. And if you tell me, “Oh, all will be revealed in the next books in the series” then I will say, “That’s not good enough.” It comes off as poor or lazy world building, and I’m really tired of YA trilogies withholding key story points for their next books, if that is the case here, because that’s not how book serieses should be written.

Also, the alternating fonts and font colour for Day and June’s chapters were distracting and a bit bothersome.

Anyway, I liked the book, I liked the story and characters, those were all very well done, but the world is so poorly explained that it really drags the rest of the book down a bit. I will continue to read this book series because I did enjoy it after all, though I had hoped for something more impressive.

My Rating: 3.5/5


Insurgent

This post first published June 20, 2012.

Author: Veronica Roth
First Published: May 2012
Publisher: HarperTeen
Series: Divergent #2
525 pages (hardcover)
 
I  liked the first book Divergent, so I was eager to read the next book in the series, Insurgent. Seems like quite a lot of people enjoyed it, but for me personally … I was rather disappointed.

Insurgent picks up immediately after the events of Divergent. It actually is just a straight continuation, and this wouldn’t be a problem except for the fact that the first book was published a year ago, and many people forgot names and events. Insurgent does nothing to help the reader remember the previous book, no flashbacks, no references, no recap. It was really hard to sympathize with Tris because of this — she would be lamenting the death of so-and-so and all I could think of was, “Who was that again? Why do I care?” Or if I did remember the character, I couldn’t remember how they died, etc. I know, I know, the author said she intentionally did not want to recap, and has written up a lovely chart to help readers with this issue (clearly, this was a problem and I’m not the only one experiencing it), but I don’t think I should have to look up a chart on the Internet to help my understanding of the story. I think it was a mistake on the author’s part to have no recapping. With a little help from the Internet, I did eventually remember everything I needed to know but the beginning was unnecessarily difficult to engage with.

Insurgent is about the war that occurs as a result of the final events of Divergent. Tris and her friends try to find out just what the Erudite and traitor Dauntless want, and prepare for a fight against them. This means trying to gain allies with the other factions, and even the factionless. While this all occurs, Tris tries to grapple with the guilt of having killed one of her good friends (from last book), and also has to deal with her slowly deteriorating relationship with Tobias/Four.

As I already mentioned, the beginning of the story was tough for the first hundred pages or so. Even if I remembered everything crystal clear from the previous book, it just felt like nothing much was happening and it wasn’t very exciting. Things didn’t seem to get much better as I approached the middle of the book either. The story just didn’t seem to have the same spark, the same excitement, that I felt when I read Divergent.

In the first book, I already mentioned how I found the world of the story — the factions segregating the population by human virtues — hard to believe and unrealistic. However, since I liked the plot a lot, I was willing to overlook it for the most part. In this second book, however, Tris is no longer hanging around only one faction; rather, she is interacting a lot more with people from other factions, so the differences between the factions was brought to the forefront. I had to tell myself that these people must be some futuristic type of human breed, because it’s just so difficult to imagine humans that live by one and only one virtue, to the extreme. And the idea of a human having more than one virtue is crazy to them! Someone who is selfless and honest? Or brave and logical? Impossible! I found it difficult to swallow, and difficult to overlook this time around.

Tris and Four’s relationship was rather exasperating. In many ways, it is your typical YA relationship of a middle book in a series — problems are popping up between them, and there’s lots of angst and stuff like that. The problem I had was that the two of them kept fighting over the exact same problem. All they argued about was “You don’t trust me!” and “No, you don’t trust me!”  It got old fast, never went anywhere, and I found myself wanting them to just break up.

It sounds like I didn’t like this book at all, but in truth, I think this book wasn’t bad, though it was only okay. The very end of the book saved it a little bit. It was exciting and action-packed, the kind of oomph I was expecting from the story. And I rather liked the cliffhanger, even if it was kind of predictable as to what was outside the wall (I didn’t know the exact details, but it wasn’t hard to generalize). I will be reading the next book though, because hey, I’ve already read the first two. And I find myself actually do wanting to find out what happens next, and I have optimistic hopes for book three.

My Rating: 2/5

1984

This post first published June 1, 2012.

Author: George Orwell
First Published:  1949
Publisher: Penguin
326 pages (paperback)
 
I told myself I will try to read more classics this year, so this is the beginnings of my attempt. I have been wanting to read 1984 for a while now. It’s one of those books where you hear a lot about it, and perhaps even know most of the entire story already, despite having not read it yet, because it is so entrenched in our culture. Terms like ‘big brother’ and ‘thought police’ are used in everyday vernacular, and they originated from this book. I suppose I set myself up to expect a lot from this book but it wasn’t exactly what I expected. I wasn’t disappointed with it, per se, though I had expected to like it a lot more. I do like it though.

1984 is the future (the book was written in 1949). The book centers around the character, Winston Smith. I guess you can say he is a pretty ordinary guy. He works as a member of the Outer Party, and on the outside, he acts just like every other Big Brother loving citizen of the country of Oceania. On the inside, however, he loathes the Party and their extremely controlling ways. When he falls in love with a woman named Julia, who also despises the Party, Winston finds his life in constant danger, as their relationship would surely be not approved by the Party. Together, the two of them are drawn to the idea of overthrowing the Party and Big Brother, and unexpectantly find a way that just might make that happen.

My favourite thing about the book is the world Orwell creates. It is scarily similar to many things happening in our world today! It’s almost like Orwell had some prophetic abilities. On the same topic, the world in the book is, of course, in many ways, very different from our real world, and I felt too much of Part 1 and a considerable chunk of Part 2 were spent describing it and giving the history. I think I would have liked it if it was much condensed or if the information was presented in a different manner. I have no problems with the content, it’s just that it started to feel less of a story, and more of an essay.

The characters were understandably a bit bland. I mean, they do live in a very controlling world where the government basically wants everyone to act like sheep and just do what they say. Anybody who sticks out is ‘vaporized’, erased from existence. So it’s completely understandable that the characters aren’t going to be the most interesting characters in the world since they are trying their best to blend in and avoid notice. Anyway, this story isn’t about characters as individuals. The focus is definitely on the society as a whole. The slogans such as FREEDOM IS SLAVERY, IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH and WAR IS PEACE sounds impossible, yet at the same time, the book explains it in such a way that it does sound possible in their world, and when you understand it, the haunting world of 1984 is made even more hopeless — a stark contrast to how the Party portrays their world, as a utopia.

I really enjoyed the ending, that was also one of my favourite things about this book. It’s definitely not a hero-saves-the-world kind of ending — quite the opposite if you know what I mean. And after reading it, I admit I felt kind of depressed because it really does make you feel utterly hopeless. It makes the world of 1984 ever more chilling, to know that even the protagonist can’t escape. You will bow to Big Brother, and if not, well, you never existed. Everyone ends up loving Big Brother, one way or another.

My Rating: 3/5

Battle Royale

This post first published October 2, 2011.

Author: Koushan Takami
Published: 1999 (English: 2003)
Publisher: VIZ Media
614 pages
 
I have been wanting to read this for a long time. I used to really be into anime and manga, and this title came up a lot as a bloody, graphic story of a bunch of students forced to kill one another. Then with The Hunger Games being released, I remembered this title again, mainly because I thought, “Wow, The Hunger Games sounds like it copied Battle Royale.” (To which I say, now that I have read it, it probably didn’t — the basic concept is the same, but the stories are completely different from one another. Anyway, I think Battle Royale is much better than The Hunger Games. I like THG, don’t get me wrong (I have it 5 stars and all), but I’m one of the people who really doesn’t understand the intense liking other readers have for it. I digress). I saw the movie first, but the movie isn’t exactly the most faithful rendering of the novel (great movie, just not the same as the book).

Battle Royale takes place in an alternate timeline in what used to be Japan, but is now the Republic of Greater East Asia. A class of 42 students are going on what they believe is a class study trip somewhere, but during the bus ride, sleeping gas is turned on and all the students are knocked out. When they awake, they find themselves on a tiny island and are told that they are this year’s chosen class to participate in the Program.

This immediately scares the daylights out of the students, and causes quite a few of them to become angry as well. The Program is, well, a program that selects, at random, one class a year to play a game where they are forced into a confined area (in this case, an island) and are forced to kill one another until one is left standing. This is the government’s way of controlling everyone — through fear and intimidation, a constant reminder that they have your lives in the palm of their hands. However, Shuya, our main character, does not want to play the game and instead, wants to strategize a way to escape. This proves to be most difficult because when the game begins, he cannot tell who is willing to play and who he can truly trust.

I loved this book. It was pure addiction to read it. As a warning though, there are many violent scenes in this book that make the violence in The Hunger Games look like a joke. Actually, I never really thought THG was a very violent book in the first place — I mean, Katniss nearly always does indirect attacks, or attacks that allow her to maintain a considerable amount of distance between herself and the enemy. In Battle Royale, we have in-your-face violence. I’m talking about bodies riddled with bullet holes, heads bashed into mush, etc. So if you can’t stomach that kind of stuff, this really isn’t the book for you so I won’t even try, but if you’re okay with it all, all the violence keeps you on the edge of your seat. It’s freaking scary because you don’t know who’s going to die next and you don’t know how it’s going to happen. And yes, some of the deaths made me squirm a bit.

Then there are all the relationships in the novel that made the novel extrenely intriguing. Okay, so I thought it was a tad odd that in one class, there was this huge web of love relationships. Half the characters seemed to have a crush on someone in the same class, which seemed like an oddly high amount to me. But these love relationships did pull on my heartstrings a bit in some scenes … especially the Hiroki scene near the end of the book. Oh, that was just so sad, and a harsh reminder that life is short so use your opportunities while you can.

There was also the trust-or-don’t-trust dynamic in the book. While I was placed in the perspective of many students in the game, a large number were shrouded in mystery. Even I did not know who to trust and who not to trust (okay, I lie — I watched the movie after all — but I know if I was completely brand new to the story, I would be very cautious of every character’s motives). You just don’t know who is pretending to be friendly, and who is playing the game for real. It’s kind of crazy how such a brutal situation reveals a person’s true nature. This was cause for some really eye-popping scenes (both literally and figuratively!)

Character-wise, I thought they were really well done. With 42 students and the instructor, it’s extremely difficult to go in depth with each character and flesh them out, so Koushan Takami didn’t do it. I believe I read somewhere once that he was completely aware that his characters are pretty one-dimensional. I’d have to agree with that, but at the same time, I think he gave great back stories to his main characters that do flesh them out a bit; only their motives are a bit one-track-minded, but hey, you’re in a survival game — you don’t really have too many other priorities at the moment besides living.

Even though it is quite a thick novel, the scenes go by quickly and the prose is easy to read. Now, with the prose, as an English speaker who has a basic understanding of conversational Japanese (studied it for 4 years and went on a student exchange trip thingy once to Japan — granted, my knowledge of the language is pretty rusty these days), I understand why some may not feel it is “good writing” because it does not sound 100% natural in the English language. However, when I think of how it may be said in Japanese, it makes perfect sense to me and does not feel weird in the slightest.
So I think I may have a bit of an advantage in regards to the writing, but honestly, everyone should know that it is difficult to judge the quality of a book’s writing when it is a translated piece of work. You can judge the translation (which I thought was fairly good), but that’s not the same as the intentions the author had when he/she was writing the book. At least, that’s my opinion. It’s the same thing with some of the behaviours of the characters. I think some of them won’t make that much sense to a person of the Western world, but if you have some basic understanding of contemporary East Asian cultures, particularly Japan of course, it would make a lot more sense and you’d realize it’s not really out of the ordinary for someone to say or do a particular thing.

Battle Royale is really a great book and makes for a thrilling read. I totally understand how it came to such popularity (and controversy!) in Japan and I am so glad that it was translated for English-speaking audiences to read and appreciate as well. If you are interested in this book at all, don’t hesitate to find a copy and read it! However, I don’t necessarily recommend reading this just because you read THG and kind of expect the same thing, because it’s VERY different and this book isn’t meant for everyone.

My Rating: 5/5

Unwind

This post first published August 12, 2011.

Author: Neal Shusterman
Published: November 6, 2007
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing
Series: Unwind #1
335 pages (hardcover)
 
Oh my gaaaawd. This book was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Shocking! Breathtaking! Moving! Touching. It’s a lot of different things. It made me want to cry. It made me ridiculously warm and fuzzy inside. It’s a MUST READ.

Unwind takes place in a dystopic future. After the Heartland War was fought in the US, the Pro-Life and Pro-Choice proponents came to a compromise: from the moment a life is conceived till the child becomes 13 years old, their life is protected by law. However, a child between the ages of 13 and 18 can be aborted, or “unwound”. 100% of their body will be systematically taken apart and used for transplants. This is also to address the issue of not enough people being organ donors. The idea is that unwinding does not technically kill the person, because all their body parts are still alive — just in a scattered state.

Connor just found out his parents, who think their son is behaving out of control, have signed the papers to have him unwound. He runs away from home, causing an accident on a highway that unites him with Risa, also bound for unwinding as she is a ward of the state that the state can no longer afford to keep, especially since, in their opinion, she has no special talents worth keeping alive for, and also Lev, a tithe who, for his entire life, has been prepared for his eventual unwinding. The three of them struggle to survive, until they are 18 at least, in a world that has already labeled them as useless members of society before they’ve been given a proper chance to prove themselves.

I always have trouble reviewing books I really, really like because I’m afraid it turns into more of a fangirl-y rambling mess. Honestly, I was blown away by this book’s story. At first I kind of raised my eyebrow at the synopsis because it didn’t sound believable that anyone would ever dare put forth an idea like ‘unwinding’ to become law, but a good writer can make his reader believe anything. And no, this book is not preach-y at all about pro-life or pro-choice. It doesn’t really side with either. It is strictly about unwinding.

One of the things I liked about this book was the little excerpts of quotes and real news stories and articles that occasionally popped up throughout the book. I think that was one of the things that helped give the unwinding concept credibility. For example, there was a quote from Albert Einstein about how humans are in delusion about how they are their own entity separate from the universe, when really, humans should know they are a part of the universe in every way possible. Einstein is probably talking about the cycle of life, but you see how one can skew a quote like this to support unwinding? The story is so crazy, but so good, and so clever.

I was completely engrossed into the story world. I was living in it, breathing in it. The characters started off as strangers to me, but by the end of the novel, I cared about them — so much that I felt their crushed spirits, I felt their sense of hopelessness, I felt their shock, and I felt their happiness. The ending was so moving and touching, I felt like I could weep tears of joy. It’s not a perfect happy ending, but it still makes you sit back and say, “Wow … that was just amazing.” It makes you wonder about what it means to be alive, the right to our own bodies and the right to live.

I’m really curious about the supposed sequel that is being written. I am not against a sequel, but with how nicely the book concluded, I’m curious as to what a sequel would entail. Perhaps different characters altogether? Regardless, I will most definitely pick up the second book.

I hope my enthusiasm is enough to convince you to pick up this book and read it. At least stick it in your TBR lists so you don’t forget about it. This book sticks with you after you read it, it is very capable of emotionally affecting its reader. I’m just in awe over this book. I love it!

My Rating: 5/5

Awaken

This post first published July 31, 2011.

Author: Katie Kacvinsky
Published: May 23, 2011
Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Books
320 pages (hardcover)
 
Awaken takes place in the year 2060, where most everyone is constantly “plugged in” to a machine or computer of some sort. Everyone is always online, behind profiles and aliases, in chatrooms and blogs. School has become completely digitalized; there is no need for classrooms anymore, just join an online school. Even when people go out, they always have their eyes glued to some sort of electronic device or another.

Our main character, 18 year old Maddie, is the daughter of a famous and influential man, the inventor of digital school. Maddie’s interesting because while she is happily content living in her digital world, she also feels like there should be something more to life, which is what led her to join some anti-digital school rebellious groups when she was 15. She was caught and has been on probation ever since. She continues trying to live her digital life as normally as possible, but she is once again conflicted when she meets Justin, a guy who loves face-to-face interactions. As Maddie gets to know him, she falls in love with him, but when she finds out he’s a part of an anti-digital school group, she wonders if he is simply using her and her status as a means to an end.

I was super excited to read this when I first heard about it. It’s a very relatable story, I feel. We’re already living in a world where social networking online is huge, and this book takes that idea to the next level by envisioning it to the extreme. I love the idea, but unfortunately, I think the story fell a little short of living up to its potential.

The actual story was actually a little boring to me. It wasn’t very exciting. I don’t really know what else to say about it — I just wasn’t feeling it, I suppose. It didn’t have enough intrigue to really have me glued to the pages. I cannot think of any scenes that left an impression in my mind.

I also didn’t really understand what the huge conflict was. Digital school was created because in the story, there was too much violence, drug usage and teen pregnancies occurring in schools. The years before the digital school programs began were filled with school shootings and bombings. So they made digital school and all kids are safe and secure inside their own homes while still getting their education. While I understand how important socializing is for kids, I didn’t understand why it was presented as the single biggest threat to personal freedom. It could be just me, but I couldn’t connect the idea of digital school with losing freedom and being controlled.

Then there is Maddie. Her actual character is quite okay, quite likeable — up to a point. When she met Justin (who I felt she had no chemistry with, just a lot of  “Omg, he is so gorgeous” rephrased in a million different ways), Maddie’s life suddenly revolved around him instead, and there was a lot of pining for him when he wasn’t around, which really isn’t the most exciting thing to read about.
Justin was also a very cookie-cutter male love interest, in terms of recent YA novels. He’s apparently drop-dead gorgeous but doesn’t know it, is protective and caring and selfless and an all-around saint, so how can Maddie not fall in love with him? He also has a personal reason as to why he cannot be with Maddie, despite being in love with her and she with him. They have a love full of anguish (sound familiar?) It was all just very predictable.

I really wanted to like this book. Despite being a technology lover, I wanted explore the idea that it may also be de-socializing people. And I did really enjoy Maddie’s diary chapters where she wrote about her changing perspectives and attitudes toward technology. Those were great and were the few times I was fully engaged in the book. The writing was also great and flowed well — this is not a badly written book. It was just boring.

My Rating: 2/5

Delirium

This post first published July 30, 2011.

Author: Lauren Oliver
Published: February 1, 2011
Publisher: HarperTeen
Series: Delirium #1
310 pages (eBook)
 
I got a Kobo eReader recently, did I tell anyone?! :P The first book I read on it is this one, Delirium. Did you know, I never noticed that the words had a face in the background until just now … haha.

This is a book I’ve heard quite a bit about, at least among my book-reading friends. Everyone’s either likes it or REALLY likes it. I’m a bit late to jump on the bandwagon, but better late than never. I fall in to the “like it” camp — it was an enjoyable read and I’d love to continue reading the series.

Delirium is a story that takes place in a future dystopic version of the city of Portland. Love has been identified as a sickness, as a disease, long ago, and people go through a procedure (called the Cure) when they are 18 to “fix” them so they do not feel love. There’s talk about brain cutting, so I imagine it’s some sort of lobotomy.

The protagonist, Lena, is going to be 18 soon, and her Cure date is in roughly 90 days (if I remember correctly) at the start of the story. Lena’s a rather obedient citizen and fully believes in the Cure, because her mother killed herself long ago, destroyed by the delirium — love. Thus, Lena has come to accept that love is a dangerous disease that must be eradicated in order to feel happiness. However, Lena’s beliefs are threatened by her best friend, Hana, who shows great interest in the idea that Invalids (unCured people living in the wilds) may possibly exist, begins listening to illegal music and attending — gasp! — illegal co-ed parties.

Her beliefs are further challenged (and pretty much destroyed) when she meets Alex, a young man posing as a Cured citizen when in reality, he is an Invalid. At first, Lena is simply interested in the idea that Invalids exist, hence her continual contact with Alex, but not much time passes before she realizes she has fallen in love. At first she is scared, thinking she has the disease and is just like her mother now, but slowly, Alex shows her that love is anything but a disease.

There’s one thing I had to kind of “get over” before I could appreciate the story, and that is the idea that people treat love as a disease. I … don’t really understand how an entire society would agree on that. In fact, in this story, people are so afraid of love that they will imprison, beat up or even execute (“death by torture”!!) those who continue exhibiting love. To me, that is TOO BIG of a leap from today’s perspective of love, which is that it is wonderful thing. All that was explained in the book was that scientists one day ‘realized’ love was a disease and later, found a cure. It’s a pretty unconvincing idea, to me. And at times, I wasn’t sure if they removed only the emotion love, or all emotions. Some characters still seemed pretty normal — just loveless — but others, like Lena’s sister Rachel, is described as being in a zombie-like state.

Ironically, it is the idea of love as a disease that had me hooked onto the story as well. I think I had to push the idea of this book being speculative out of my mind (which a lot of dystopian novels traditionally are), and instead look at it a different way, as simply a story with message underneath. There’s many different kind of messages you can take away from the book, but I think overall, it’s about the importance of love, of sacrifice, and of life. I think at one point, Lena wonders what is the point of living if there is no love? Just going through the motions of living without a care for anything? Love as a disease is a really interesting idea, so that is why I ended up liking the story, even though I didn’t particularly buy the whole idea of it (at least, the way it was sold to me by Lena).

The idea was backed up with lots of in-story government paraphernalia, one at the beginning of every chapter. An example they use is the story of Romeo and Juliet as a cautionary tale against love. They also have ‘banned dangerous quotes’ which, to us, talk about how powerful love is, but to them, is about how people crazy people are, if for example, they are willing to die for love. The little snippets at the beginning of each chapter is a very nice touch and really adds to the story world.

I also liked Lena. She starts off as a very obedient citizen, fully believing in love as a sickness. In fact, she’s scared that love is ‘genetic’ and she’ll end up like her mother — crazed by love. However, she has just enough curiosity and daringness to see for herself if it is really all as bad as the government says. I liked reading about her changing attitudes towards love. It’s admirable of her to try to think for herself when the whole world is trying to think for her. With that all being said, Lena can be rather melodramatic at times, and truth be told, she’s not the world’s most interesting narrator.
If you like dystopian novels or YA romances, I think you’ll like Delirium as well.

My Rating: 3.5/5

Blood Red Road

This post first published July 7, 2011.

Author: Moira Young
Published: May 2011
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing
Series: Dustlands #1
464 pages (eBook)

 
This is another book I read on PulseIt, and this time around, I really, really liked what I read!

Blood Red Road takes place in the distant future. Us humans in our own present time are known as the Wreckers, and I guess we did something awful to earn that name. The setting in this book is in a harsh, dry, desert dustland. There isn’t a lot of modern technology (‘Wrecker tech’) available, except for what is salvaged from landfills. Human civilization seems to have taken a step backwards in time in this book.

The story is about a girl named Saba, who lives with her twin brother Lugh, younger sister Emmi and their father, Pa, in Silverlake, an ironic name since it’s just a dry desert. Their closest neighbour is three days’ walk away, so they’re pretty isolated. The children are oblivious about what the outside world is like, but they are, for the most part, happily content living where they are.

Saba’s whole world changes when four horsemen appear. They kill their Pa and kidnap Lugh. Saba is torn about the loss of her twin brother, the person closest to her in the whole world, and sets out on a journey to save him, her little sister in tow. However, the world outside is very different from the world she’s grown up in. It’s a dog eat dog world, a world of slavery and cage fighting, all ruled by one mad king. Saba only wants to save Lugh, but her encounters with the all female rebel group, the Free Hawks, and a flirtatious boy named Jack, Saba is persuaded into bringing down the corruption.
One of the most unique things about this novel is the writing. The entire narration is from Saba’s first person point of view, and she — along with everyone else in the book except one character — speaks in a very distinct way. I can’t tell, it’s either hillbilly or Texan or something. But anyway, the point is, the entire narration is written in this particular way of speaking, so all the words are spelled exactly the way they are pronounced: “yer” “cain’t” “ezzackly” “unnerstand” “pertect” etc. It takes a little getting used to, but I found I really enjoyed reading the book that way, and it certainly gives the characters more flavor. On the other hand, a thing I didn’t like about the writing was the lack of quotation marks around dialogue. It drove me nuts, to be honest; for example, when a new paragraph starts, I’m not sure if it’s someone else talking, or Saba continuing the narration.

I really liked the story and watching Saba mature throughout. She starts off, as her little sister Emmi would say, as a “meanie” — and it’s true, Saba isn’t the nicest girl in the world. She’s hard and stubborn and hell bent on getting her twin brother Lugh back. She’ll break her promises to do it if she must. One of the harshest things about her is that she would have rather Emmi been kidnapped than Lugh — and she admits she wouldn’t be chasing after Emmi if she was the one taken. Personally, I think she was just saying that, but later on, when Emmi is in danger (and Emmi gets herself in trouble quite a number of times), Saba is always there for her, as reluctant as she is. As the story progresses, Saba seems to grow up, in a way. Physically, she’s had to endure a lot (she becomes captured and forced to do cage fighting for others’ entertainment), but emotionally, she realizes that she can’t only be caring about her own needs. She realizes she can’t just tell Emmi to go away all the time — Saba is all Emmi has left in the world. And when she joins up with the Free Hawks and Jack for her own advantage, she realizes she can’t sneak away from them after all the help they’ve given her.

Besides Saba, the rest of the characters were amazingly written as well. I have two favourite characters: Emmi (I don’t know, I just found her so adorable, even though Saba finds her such a burden) and Nero, Saba’s pet crow. Yep, even a pet crow was bursting with personality in this book (Nero’s just awesome). Jack was pretty suave as well, and I loved the relationship he built with Saba. They bicker a lot like kindergartners who won’t admit they like one another, it’s cute.

The last half of the novel pales a bit in comparison to the first. The writing is fantastic throughout, but I think it’s the story. It’s much stronger, more interesting and intriguing in the first half — well, Saba is caught in quite the life or death situation — whereas the second half was more about journeying and her relationship with Jack. Don’t get me wrong, the entire book is really good, but I felt there was a noticeable difference.

However, don’t let that deter you from reading this book. It’s not really sci-fi, but it’s definitely one of the best dystopian-ish YA novels out there! I’m excitedly waiting for the sequel to come out now :)

My Rating: 4.5/5

Wither

This post first published July 4, 2011. 

Author: Lauren DeStefano
Published: March 2011
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing
Series: The Chemical Garden #1
358 pages (hardcover)
 
For most people, when they hear a book isn’t that great, they’ll probably decide not to read it. When friends tell me a certain book isn’t that great, a lot of the time I do the opposite: I read it, because I’m curious. Plus, it’s science fiction and deals with genetic engineering and that kind of stuff, and I love books like that. So that’s the story of why I decided to read Wither.

The future of North America is bleak in this book. Science has eradicated every disease that’s plagued humankind (cancer, etc.) but there is a serious downside to this — the children of these new disease-free humans (called the First Generations) can’t live past the ages of 20 (females) or 25 (males). This has, somehow, resulted in humans kidnapping young girls all over the country and forcing them into polygamous marriages for the wealthy. The girls are expected to be baby factories, keeping the human race alive until scientists can discover the cure for the virus.

Wither centers around sixteen year old Rhine Ellery who is orphaned. She lives with her twin brother Rowan in Manhattan, working for pennies in order to survive this harsh world. One day Rhine gets kidnapped and before she knows it, she is now one of the many wives of Linden Ashby, a wealthy man, whose father is Vaughn, a prominent doctor/scientist/First Generation who is trying to discover the antidote to the virus that claims people’s lives before they hit adulthood. Despite having almost anything she wants now, Rhine wants nothing more than to escape and find her brother.

The biggest issue I had with this book is the story world. Much like Divergent, it’s simply unbelievable why society would decide to move in this particular direction, based on how our world works today. The story takes place in the USA (names such as Florida and Manhattan are still used), and I know it’s supposed  to be far in the future, but despite that, I don’t see how polygamy can become legal all over the place, how kidnapping girls is the norm, how the SIX OTHER CONTINENTS can disappear off the face of the world in a fictional WW3 … (although to be fair, I read here that the Americans believe they’re the only ones left on the planet, and there’s like this huge conspiracy or something. But then, where’d the Internet go, in this future?? Surely someone would have have run into other people on the Internet if it still existed. There’s dozens of ways people can discover they’re not the only people left in the world). Where is the government in all this? The police?? Also, in the book, they kill the ‘undesirable’ girls. I’m not sure what made them undesirable, but this really bugged me because if everyone really was panicking as much as they did in this book and trying to pump babies out to save the human race, wouldn’t you need all the wombs you can get?

Besides the story world, I also found the concept of the cure/virus kind of … plothole-ish (can I make that an adjective?) At first I thought the idea was really neat, and I was looking forward to reading about it in the book, but it soon became clear that the idea was not thoroughly fleshed out. Think about it: they eradicated all diseases. Every single one. Okay. But the book does not explain exactly how was that done. So my natural assumption is that they got rid of the diseases in people who had them. Okay. But what about the people who never had any diseases, the so-called ‘natural humans’ who were perfectly healthy already? There is no reason that they cannot mate naturally and keep having offspring, and the human race basically goes on as usual. So I was pondering on this and I thought, “Okay, maybe they innoculated every single human being in North America, regardless if they are healthy or diseased, with this new medicine or whatever it is.” But somehow that doesn’t seem plausible either (case in point: when the swine flu pandemic/hype was here where I live, the government offered free vaccinations for every single citizen … and way less than half took advantage of it). My point is, the concept is a cool idea for a story, but it’s not explained, so I’m stuck here trying to come up with my own theories as to how this could all work. And that really distracts from reading the book properly.

The actual plot of the book isn’t that bad, though it is a little on the dull side. Most of the narrative consists of Rhine living in her gigantic mansion with the husband she shares with two other wives. She keeps wanting to escape but doesn’t make much of an effort to do it until the very end of the book. So you can probably get away with reading the beginning of the book, skip the middle and read the end, and wouldn’t really have missed much. I mean, it’s alright, but it’s a bit of disappointing.
The main character, Rhine, is really bland. She has no personality and I don’t understand much of her thinking processes. However, other than Rhine, I actually liked the rest of the cast. The other wives were interesting and had something unique about them, whether it was their backstory or personality. The two males — Linden, the husband, and Gabriel, the servant — weren’t bad either. Gabriel was really cute with hiding the candies in Rhine’s meals, and heroic in trying to save Rhine in the hurricane; Linden was a super devoted husband (despite having three wives to look over) and to be honest, I don’t know why Rhine didn’t fall in love with him, he seems like a good guy. Super naive, but still good. It’s the father, Vaughn, that’s the creeper, really.

Wither had potential. I thought most of the characters were decent, I had no qualms with the writing, and the plot, in all honesty, isn’t that bad. It’s the story world that really drags this book down. It’s definitely not thought out properly, leaving you to fill in the gaps yourself, which totally distracts from reading the book. You can’t properly immerse yourself into the story because you’re too busy asking questions in your head.

As a side note, I read the last chapter while listening to Charice’s song, “Note To God” and I have to say, they went together really well, heh.

My Rating: 2/5

Divergent

This post first published July 1, 2011.

Author: Veronica Roth
Published: May 2011
Publisher: HarperCollins Children’s Books
Series: Divergent #1
487 pages (hardcover)
 
Being a dystopian fiction fan, and the fact that this book was quite hyped, had me interested in reading Divergent for a while now. There’s a lot of YA dystopian novels entering the market these days, and not all of it good, but I was pretty optimistic about this book. While I ended up liking it, I’m still kind of “WTF” about the world. I don’t get it.

The story takes place in a future version of Chicago. The population is split into five factions: Amity (the peaceful), Dauntless (the brave), Abnegation (the selfless), Erudite (the knowledgable) and Candor (the honest). The five factions were created so that the people can live in peace, living amongst people who are like them. On one’s sixteenth birthday, one must choose the faction that one will live in for the rest of one’s life.

Beatrice and her brother, Caleb are sixteen now (are they twins? book never says) and it is time for them to choose which faction to devote their lives to. They were born into an Abnegation family, but they do not necessarily have to stay with the faction they are born into. All the sixteen year olds must take an aptitude test to determine which faction they are most suited for, although which faction you join is still ultimately up to you. Beatrice’s aptitude test results are not as straightforward as everyone else’s: Beatrice doesn’t fit into any of the five factions neatly — she’s Divergent. She is told to keep it a secret, because being Divergent is a bad thing, apparently. Pondering on what being Divergent could possibly mean right up to the moment where she must choose, Beatrice decides on Dauntless. However, choosing the faction is not the end of the trials. Now Beatrice enters a grueling initiation period (or in other words, she voluntarily gets tortured), where she must prove that she has what it takes to be Dauntless, or be thrown out to live in the streets with the Factionless.

There are a lot of things I liked about this book, and overall, I definitely do like the story, however, I will start off with the thing I really didn’t like:

The thing I didn’t really like was the dystopian world Roth created. Dystopian settings should still be believable. But in Divergent, I had a hard time buying any of it. It just doesn’t seem plausible. I think this quote from a Goodreads member sums it up:
Now, what I would like to know is, which facking genius came up with THAT idea? Who was it that got up and said, “Hold up peeps. I’ve totally got it. We’ll DIVIDE the city by forcing everyone to choose ONE AND ONLY ONE principle virtue and we’ll even make it obvious by getting them to wear different colours so that there will be no question whatsoever as to which group they belong. SEPARATION is the way forward.”
This is all supposed to encourage peace, but as shown in the book, it only caused faction rivalry. It simply doesn’t make sense to me why society would evolve into this strange system. If Divergent was a fantasy novel, I think this would make more sense and I think I would like it more, but it’s not, so it confuses me. And you HAVE to pick a faction or else become factionless (in other words, homeless). If you don’t do well in the initiation, you also become factionless. Then they go complain about the factionless people draining their resources. I don’t understand why society would create homeless people so easily like this, especially when most societies (Western, anyway) try to encourage and help the homeless today.

Okay. Rant over.

Besides that one part, I actually really enjoyed the story. It is a bit reminiscent of The Hunger Games with the division of society and the brutal fighting and violence that Beatrice has to endure during her initiation; however, I think this is significantly different enough that it is quite original to me. Most of the plot consists of the initiation trial, which may sound kind of boring, but is actually fast paced and thrilling. Not a lot of authors can write fight scenes that create tension and excitement, but Veronica Roth definitely can do it without making it sound like you’re just reading a string of actions. The plot isn’t perfect, but I definitely enjoyed reading it and I liked the ending a lot as well, even though the part where you finally figure out what being Divergent means was kind of anti-climatic (and it turns out being Divergent doesn’t mean much). The ending appropriately concludes this book, but leaves just enough story left to be continued and expanded in a sequel (and from what I read, this is to be a trilogy). That’s the way you write the ending to a book in a planned series (cough, cough Elixir …)

I also quite liked the protagonist, Beatrice, which is surprising to me because I was prepared to dislike her, based on the fact that I haven’t really been feeling the protagonists lately in YA dystopians/paranormal romances (which are the genres I generally gravitate to in YA books, ironically). But Beatrice was interesting because she wasn’t a Mary Sue and she wasn’t boring. She’s feisty, kick-ass and, dare I say, a bit vindictive? When people pick on her, she wants to exact some kind of revenge. When her friend-turned-enemy tried to kill her but then asked for her forgiveness, I was glad she didn’t go the angelic route; she told him straight up that she will kill him if he comes near her again. To me, that is a realistic response to her situation. Or at least, the response I would say (I mean, he tried to kill her …) Beatrice was realistic to me, and I liked that. Okay, well, not 100% realistic (parents dying is just a minor event, but romantic interest potentially being hurt? Oh no!!) but still, good enough for a YA.

Overall, I really liked the story.  It was exciting, action packed and had a kick-butt heroine. I enjoyed the writing as well, despite normally being an anti-fan of present tense. If I didn’t have such qualms with the world it is set in, I definitely would have liked it more and rated it higher, but as it is right now, I think it’s good and I would definitely continue reading the rest of the books in this trilogy once they are published.

My Rating: 3.5/5

Gool

This post first published May 27, 2011.

Author: Maurice Gee
Published: September 2010
Publisher: Orca Book Publishers
Series: The Salt Trilogy #2
215 pages (hardcover)
 
I read the first book, Salt, a long time ago, and I remember liking it but not blown away by it. I was a little hesitant to take out this book, Gool, from the library, because of that, but I thought, “It’s just a little over 200 pages … why not?” I read the whole thing in a few hours’ time.

Gool takes place a generation later, with the children of Hari and Pearl, and the children’s friends, as the main characters. The story begins with Hari taking Xantee and Lo — his own two kids — and four other kids from the nearby village, on a regular scouting mission. Unfortunately, they run into a huge jellyfish-like monster — the gool — that tried to eat them. The party luckily manages to escape, but parts of the gool had latched itself onto Hari’s body, slowly sucking away at his life. They can’t get it off. They only way to save Hari is to destroy the mother monster.

But the gool they encountered is just a spawn of the mother monster. Tealeaf (from Salt) tells the children of a story, possibly a myth, when the gool existed and a fisherman killed it. The children decide they need to go into the ruined city of Belong and find the libraries of books there, to find the true story as to how the fisherman killed the gool. To do so, they decide they need the help of Tarl, the Dog King, Hari’s father and Xantee and Lo’s grandfather.

Gool was okay … it wasn’t as good as Salt, but it can stand on its own as a story. You really don’t even need to have read Salt to understand Gool. This book is really average, in my opinion. The plot was quite simple and straightforward. I didn’t find it that exciting to be honest; the majority of the novel seemed to consist of Xantee and Duro (and whoever else happened to with them) traveling in the jungles and forests. It had some good scenes, such as the ending, but overall, the book felt almost … passive. And a bit boring. Nothing really stands out in my mind. It isn’t horrible, it just doesn’t really grab at you the way you hope for a good book to.

Xantee is arguably the main character in this novel. I was a little bummed that Hari and Pearl aren’t the main characters anymore, but at least Hari is still an important character — the novel revolves around saving his life, after all. Xantee was alright, but she kind of bothered me at times, especially near the ending, when she turned all Mary Sue. The other characters were kind of boring as well. I don’t know. None of the characters were particularly interesting to me, the way Hari and Pearl were in the first book.

This is a really weak follow up to Salt. It is okay, but I am not sure if ‘okay’ is enough to get me to read the third book. (Well, maybe if it’s short like this one I will). The story the author created in Salt was intriguing, and the gool monster in Gool sounded promising for a new story, but I definitely felt quite underwhelmed by this book. I don’t think Salt even needed a sequel, to be honest, and after reading Gool, I only continue to think so.

My Rating: 2/5

The Year Of The Flood

This post first published May 19, 2011.

Author: Margaret Atwood
Published: 2008
Publisher: Nan A. Talese
Series: MaddAdam #2
431 pages (hardcover)
 
After I finished reading this book, I was informed that it is a part of Atwood’s Oryx and Crake world. Something of a side-quel. And I was also informed that it really would be better if I had read Oryx and Crake first before The Year of the Flood. So now I feel kind of sad that I possibly cheated myself out of a better reading experience by reading this one first. I had no idea that this book was part of a series, since I think it did very well as a stand alone novel. Well, you can bet that I am definitely going to seek out Oryx and Crake now …

Anyway, from what I know, the events in The Year of the Flood kind of happen alongside Oryx and Crake, so it is not a sequel per se, but rather a different perspective of the story. In The Year of the Flood, the story has two main female narrators, Toby and Ren, and it is set in the far future. They both join the environmental religious group, God’s Gardeners, led by a man called Adam One. Toby is not a true believer of the faith, but was offered safety in their group from her boss/rapist, so she stays with the God’s Gardeners as a hard worker, and even rises in their ranks. Ren, who is only a kid really, is originally from a Compound (rich, elite) and she joins the God’s Gardeners because her mother Lucerne is infatuated with one of the Gardeners, Zeb. She leaves her husband and drags her daughter along behind her into the Gardeners’ circle.

The first half of the book mainly speaks of the events that happened pre-Flood: how the two joined the Gardeners, how they adapted (or coped) with the Gardeners’ way of living, how they got along with the group. The Gardeners are pacifists, anti-meat, and believe that nothing is truly garbage; everything can be reused. Because they take these beliefs to the extreme, Toby and Ren are kind of bewildered by it all at first. All the while, Adam One is preaching about the Waterless Flood that will cleanse the world of most humans so that a new Eden may grow. The latter half of the book are events that occur post-Flood, which consisted of how the survivors survived; their search for other survivors, their personal struggles. All the while I was reading the book, I couldn’t help but think that the world Atwood created was just so cruel and wicked that perhaps destroying it via a Waterless Flood was the only way to cleanse it.

I enjoyed this novel, especially the first three-fourths of it. Like I said, I never read Oryx and Crake, so for me, there was a bit of wonder in reading about this dystopic world, and curiosity to drive me along. The corporations, the technology and gene melding, and the desire to be more organic and natural are all things we are familiar with in our to world, but they are twisted to the extreme in this book. The book horrified me at times (in an oh-my-god kind of way), especially SecretBurgers, the restaurant/fast-food establishment that serves mystery meat burgers. And by mystery meat, I mean it could be anything; the characters have hinted it could be anything from an alley cat to mice to perhaps even people.

I really liked the characters, they were wonderfully realistic. It’s funny how even when the world is very different, and is possibly coming to an end, human beings still act like human beings. There are those who are greedy and selfish. Children still act like children. And there will still be love and friendship … which sounds kind of hopeful, yet somehow the book still paints a rather depressing picture of these emotions. This is a grim, grim book.

The ending of the book, perhaps the last sixty pages or so, were not as good in my opinion — just that I found it a bit sluggish, and I was no longer sure what direction the book was heading in at that point. From what I read online, apparently the ending is when The Year of the Flood really starts to tie in with Oryx and Crake — so perhaps since I never read O&C, that is why I wasn’t so interested in the ending. Still, I think this is a really good book, especially for lovers of dystopian fiction. It may be a bleak story, and it doesn’t exactly end off on a happy note (more of a cliffhanger, or a question mark, haha), but certainly worth reading.

My Rating: 4/5

Wednesday, September 30, 2015

Catching Fire

This post first published May 13, 2011.

Author: Suzanne Collins
Published: September 2009
Publisher: Scholastic Press
Series: The Hunger Games #2

391 pages (hardcover)
 
Yay, I finally got myself a copy of Catching Fire so I can continue where The Hunger Games left off. I also have myself a copy of Mockingjay so I can jump right into the last book of the trilogy too without having to wait!
We left off in The Hunger Games with Katniss and Peeta both winning the Games. Having two victors instead of the usual one has had reverberating effects across the country of Panem. Katniss, the main character and our narrator, is shocked to find the President casually sitting in her home one day. Under the guise of coming to congratulate her and preparing her for the upcoming tour of the country, the President warns Katniss that her little act of love with Peeta hasn’t fooled him or other people in the country. He and many others know she is trying to fool the government into allowing the both of them to live, and he isn’t buying it. He warns her she better convince him, and everyone else, of her and Peeta’s undying love for one another, for their sake and her family’s, for you see, by allowing two victors, they are showing defiance against the Capitol’s rules.

However, as the tour begins, Katniss learns that she has unknowingly spearheaded a rebellion that is slowly but surely growing across the country. Unknowingly, she has become a symbol of hope for the rebels. Just as Katniss decides to start embracing this rebellion, the President announces that the next Hunger Games is going to be composed of previous victors — putting Katniss right back into that arena of death that she just barely escaped from a year ago.

Overall, I liked the story, especially the idea of a rebellion forming because of Katniss, although I was feeling slightly exasperated in a  “Are you effing kidding me?” way when I found out she had to be going back in the arena. I didn’t want to read The Hunger Games Round Two. I was expecting a continuation of the story, not the first book repackaged. In some ways, it was the same thing all over again — the interviews, the training, the arena — but the motivations were all different this time. At the present moment, I’m kind of neutral to that part of the plot.

One thing that I appreciate in this book (and the one before) is that the story moves quickly, never boring me. There’s no needless information bogging you down, and neither are you ever missing out or confused about anything. On the topic of writing though, one thing I noticed is that her writing has a very … monotonous quality to it. Katniss just describes things as they are, putting very little to no emotion in what she is saying. Even with feelings being hurt, tension in the air and people dying. It’s kind of strange and bothers me a little, but I guess it just kind of contributes to the fast pace of the story. I’m not sure if I noticed this robot-like voice when I read The Hunger Games, but I notice it now.

I’m not too crazy about the love triangle thing that is emerging in this novel. For one, it’s like, is it neccesary? I don’t think it adds that much to the story; in fact, I think you can take out Gale and still have essentially the same story. Secondly, Peeta and Gale are like … exactly the same characters. Both kind of bland, both desperately in love with Katniss for some reason. They are two characters with the same personality. There is really very little to differentiate between the two boys. So I don’t understand what the problem is, Katniss — just choose one of them, they’re the same!
I think this book is, in my opinion, a solid three: enjoyable but nothing special. I haven’t read book three yet, but I get the feeling this is one of those in-between books — there to bridge the time between two others. I loved The Hunger Games, and I see big things, large consequences, in store in Mockingjay, but I get the feeling that Catching Fire will be easily forgotten in my mind.

Anyway, to sum it all up — you’re going to probably end up reading this book if you’re planning to read this series, so whether I recommend it to you or not doesn’t really matter :P My personal opinion is that this is an okay book, but it kind of fades in the back of my mind — the first book did a good job of making an impression on me; this one, not so much, although the ending does have me wanting more ;)

My Rating: 3/5